Here are the 10 best Door County hotels:
- Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
- Open Hearth Lodge
- Pheasant Park Resort
- Bay Breeze Resort
- Country House Resort
- High Point Inn
- Harbor Guest House
- The Water Street Inn
- Holiday Music Motel
- Gordon Lodge
This page contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on the link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This helps us provide content to help you plan life-changing travel experiences. Thanks!
Best Door County Hotels
Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
The all-around best hotel in Door County is Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort, known for satisfying a wide range of visitors. Nearly every room has waterfront views, and the resort is conveniently located near Sturgeon Bay and northern Door County attractions. Guests enjoy clean facilities, friendly staff, romantic covered balconies, separate bedrooms for families, and fully equipped kitchens. Amenities include indoor and outdoor pools, a hot tub, sauna, fitness center, and complimentary paddleboats. While the resort offers stunning sunsets and scenic views, it lacks a private beach. Nearby attractions include Cave Point County Park (13.7 miles) and Peninsula State Park (21.8 miles).
My Perspective
I would choose Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort if I wanted to ensure great views and if walkability weren’t a concern of mine. To me, this hotel is a good all-around people-pleaser, with nice facilities and a beautiful setting. I would look elsewhere if I want to ditch the car for the weekend, which I like to do sometimes.
Check Availability
Check availability at Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort right away if you’re interested. Door County’s best hotels book up months in advance, especially during prime tourist season. If you find a room, go ahead and book it so that you don’t miss out on vacationing in this lovely place.
Open Hearth Lodge
Open Hearth Lodge is the best pet-friendly hotel in Door County, WI, but you don’t need to be a pet lover to enjoy it. Families and couples rave about its clean facilities and welcoming staff. A standout feature is the complimentary continental breakfast, a rarity in the area and a bonus for families.
Open Hearth Lodge offers accommodations ranging from standard rooms to two-bedroom apartments, with options for whirlpool tubs and pet-friendly stays. Amenities include free Wi-Fi, an indoor pool, hot tub, sauna, gym, and spacious outdoor grounds with BBQ grills and a fireplace. Located 1.2 miles from Sister Bay, it’s near popular attractions like Peninsula State Park (4.0 miles) and Ephraim Public Beach (1.4 miles).
While not waterfront or walkable, the lodge provides great value for families, couples, and pet owners.
My Perspective
I would choose this hotel gladly for my family or if I were travelling with a pet. If I were looking for something romantic or walkable, I would look at other options.
Check Availability
Check availability for Open Hearth Lodge right away if this property interests you. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Pheasant Park Resort
Pheasant Park Resort in Sister Bay, Door County, is a top choice for families, couples, and all travelers. Families will love the spacious 2- and 3-bedroom suites, playground, and indoor/outdoor pools. Couples can enjoy the walkable location, with dining and shopping just steps away.
Accommodations include suites with hot tubs, full kitchens, fireplaces, and balconies. Amenities feature free Wi-Fi, pools, a gym, sauna, BBQ grills, and more. While not pet-friendly and lacking beach access, Pheasant Park offers clean, spacious rooms and an unbeatable location near Sister Bay’s downtown attractions. Nearby highlights include Peninsula State Park and Ephraim Public Beach.
My Perspective
I would choose Pheasant Park resort if I were staying with my family or a large group. I would also select this if I wanted something walkable. If I were traeveling with my dog or wanted water views, I would look at other properties.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Pheasant Park Resort, do not hesitate. Lodging in Sister Bay and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Bay Breeze Resort
Bay Breeze Resort is Door County’s top-rated hotel with a private beach, thanks to its waterfront location, family-friendly atmosphere, outdoor pool, and stunning sunsets over Green Bay. Located at 9844 Water Street in Ephraim, WI, it offers easy access to Peninsula State Park and nearby attractions.
Accommodations include family rooms, king suites, and queen or king rooms, with amenities like free Wi-Fi, fireplaces, and whirlpool tubs. Guests enjoy an outdoor pool, hot tub, EV charging stations, and a private sandy beach.
Pros: Private beach, family-friendly, great views
Cons: No indoor pool, limited walkability
My Perspective
I would choose Bay Breeze Resort for beautiful water views and easy beach access. If I were looking for something more walkable or for a romantic getaway, I might go elsewhere.
Check Availability
If you are interested in checking availability for Bay Breeze Resort, do not hesitate. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Door County Hotel for Couples: Country House Resort
Country House Resort is a casually elegant hotel with water views of Sister Bay. This lovely atmosphere in combination with their adult-only policy is why we have chosen the Country House Resort as the Best Sister Bay Hotel for Couples.
Country House Resort is great for:
- Couples
- Pet lovers
- Water views
Country House Resort is on 27 acres of wooded land right on the shores of Green Bay. Water views abound at this property, and a trail leads through the woods and along the bay to downtown Sister Bay.
Accomodations
Country House Resort offers the following accommodation types:
- Single king rooms
- Double king rooms
- Single queen rooms
- Double queen rooms
Amenities
In-room amenities at Country House Resort include:
- Free Wi-Fi
- Pet-friendly rooms
- Water view rooms
- Rooms with balconies
Facility amenities include:
- Hot tub
- Garden area with lounge furniture
Location
Country House Resort is located at 2468 Sunnyside Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234. It is set on a 27-acre property that offers a quiet and peaceful setting with water views that is not far from some of Door County’s best attractions.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Sister Bay: 1.0 miles
- Ephraim Public Beach: 0.9 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 20.0 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 11.0 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 4.9 miles
Pros
- Great for couples
- Expansive, park-like grounds
- Pet-friendly
- Water views
Cons
- Not family-friendly
- Not especially walkable
Learn More
Country House Resort is the best hotel for couples in Sister Bay, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about Country House Resort before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Country House Resort, do not hesitate. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Door County Hotel for the Winter: High Point Inn
High Point Inn is the best hotel in Door County for the Winter. We gave it this rating due to the fact that it is open year-round, and also because it has fireplaces in every room. Imagine spending a day out in the snow of Door County and coming back to your own toasty fire!
But, High Point Inn isn’t just great for the winter. You’ll love spending time here in any season.
High Point Inn is great for:
- Families
- Groups
- Couples
- Winter stays
Accomodations
High Point Inn has the following accommodation types:
- 3 bedroom suites with 1 king bed and 2 queen beds. Sleeps up to 8.
- 2 bedroom suites with 1 king bed and 1 queen bed. Sleeps up to 6.
- 1 bedroom suites with 1 king bed. Sleeps up to 4.
- 1 bedroom suites with 2 queen beds. Sleeps up to 4.
Amenities
In-room amenities vary based on the type of accommodation, but they include:
- Cable TV
- Fireplaces
- Fully equipped kitchens
- Free Wi-Fi
Facility amenities include:
- Indoor pool
- Outdoor pool
- Hot tub
- Gym
- Conference room
Location
High Point Inn is located at 10386 N Water St, Ephraim, WI 54211. This is about 2 miles east of downtown Ephraim and 2 miles west of downtown Sister Bay.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Ephraim: 2.0 miles
- Ephraim Public Beach: 2.4 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 19.1 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 11.4 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 3.1 miles
Pros
- Open year-round
- Fireplaces
- Indoor and outdoor pools
Cons
- Not walkable
- No water views
Learn More
High Point Inn is the best hotel for the Winter in Door County, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about the High Point Inn before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for the High Point Inn, do not hesitate. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Hotel in Door County for Boaters: Harbor Guest House
The best hotel in Door County for boaters is Harbor Guest House. We are rating this the best hotel in Door County for boaters because it has a private marina with transient slips for boaters looking for lodging. Exit your hotel and get right in your boat to spend the day on the water.
But, you don’t have to be a boater to enjoy staying at Harbor Guest House. Harbor Guest House is right on Eagle Harbor and in the heart of Fish Creek. This is the place to stay if you want to see amazing sunsets over the bay of Green Bay right from your place of lodging. And, you can enjoy convenient walkability to Fish Creek’s charming downtown.
Harbor Guest House is great for:
- Couples
- Families
- Boaters
Accommodations
Harbor Guest House offers the following accommodation types:
- One-bedroom condo suites
- Two-bedroom condo suites
All suites have a full kitchen, living room, balcony or patio, fireplace, and water views.
Amenities
In-room amenities include:
- Waterfront views
- Full kitchen
- Living room
- Fireplace
- Balcony or patio
- Wi-Fi
Facility amenities include:
- Grill
- Marina with transient boat slips
- Fire pit
- Bike rental
Pros
- Waterfront
- Great for boaters
- Walkable
- Amazing sunsets
- Fireplaces
Cons
- No swimming pool
- No hot tub
- Busy area
Location
Right on the shore of Eagle Harbor in the bay of Green Bay, Harbor Guest House has one of the best locations of any hotel in Door County.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Fish Creek: 0.2 miles
- Fish Creek Beach: 0.4 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 16.9 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 14.7 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 0.9 miles
Learn More
Harbor Guest House is the best hotel for boaters in Door County. Families and outdoors enthusiasts will love this property with lots of amenities. Perhaps you need to learn more about Harbor Guest House before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Harbor Guest House, do not hesitate. Lodging in Fish Creek and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Most Charming Hotel in Door County: The Water Street Inn
The most charming hotel in Door County is The Water Street Inn.
This hotel is located in a historic white clapboard building from 1897. This quaint gem sists right on the shores of Green Bay in Ephraim, one of the most historic villages in Door County.
Charm is all around you when you stay here. From the gorgeous water views, to the quaint building you’ll be staying in, to the old-world feel of Ephraim.
The Water Street Inn is great for:
- Walkability
- Water views
- Families
- Couples
Accomodations
The Water Street Inn has the following accommodation types:
- Double queen rooms
- Single queen rooms
- Single king rooms
- Suites
- Water view rooms
Amenities
The Water Street Inn has the following site amenities to help you have a great stay:
- Private beach
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Free bicycle rental
- Free kayak rental
- Free Wifi
- Outdoor fireplace
In addition, The Water Street Inn has the following in-room amenities:
- Refrigerator
- Coffee machine
- Hair dryer
- Flat-screen TV
Pros
- Waterfront
- Water views
- Private beach
- Lots of charm
- Walkable
Cons
- Near busy road
- Rooms smaller than some more modern hotels
Location
The Water Street Inn is located at 944 Water St S, Ephraim, WI 54211. This is a great location for water views, walkable accessibility to the village of Ephraim, and the rest of Door County.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Ephraim: 0.4 miles
- Cana Island Lighthouse: 10.7 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 1.1 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 17.3 miles
Learn More
The Water Street Inn is the most charming hotel in Door County. Perhaps you need to learn more about this property before booking.
Check Availability
But, perhaps you are ready to check availability for Water Street Inn. If you like what you see, don’t hesitate to make your booking now. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County fills up months and sometimes even a year in advance. Act now, so that you don’t lose out on a chance at your Door County vacation.
Best Budget Hotel in Door County: Holiday Music Motel
The best budget hotel in Door County is the Holiday Music Motel in downtown Sturgeon Bay.
Not only is the Holiday Music Motel the best budget-friendly hotel in Door County, it is also one of the most unique. It is a retro-remodeled property with a classic music theme throughout. At every corner, you will be greeted by memorabilia for mmusicians like Elvis and Chuck Berry.
It even has a recording studio built in to the property!
Guests love the unique decor and theme, and they also love the great location. The Holiday Music Motel is right in the heart of downtown Sturgeon Bay, the only city in Door County. You’ll be right near Sturgeon Bay’s shops, restaurants, waterfront, and other attractions.
Pet lovers are in luck here, as pets are welcome. Families might want to think about staying elsewhere, as children under the age of five are not allowed.
The Holiday Music Motel is great for:
- Travelers on a budget
- Music lovers
- Pet lovers
- Walkability
Accomodations
The Holiday Music Motel has the following accomodations:
- Double full bed
- 1 full bed, 1 queen bed
- 1 queen bed
- Two double beds
- 1 king bed
- 1 queen bed
- Pet-friendly rooms
Amenities
Amenities at the Holiday Music Motel include:
- Coffee maker
- Refrigerator
- Live music performances
- Recording studio
- Outdoor fireplace
Pros
- Budget friendly
- Pet friendly
- Walkable
- Unique decor
Cons
- Not family friendly
- Few amenities
Location
The Holiday Music Motel is located at 30 N 1st Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235. This is right in the heart of downtown Sturgeon Bay, the only city in Door County. This is a walkable location with access to Sturgeon Bay’s waterfront, restaurants, shops, and attractions.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Sturgeon Bay: 0.1 miles
- Door County Maritime Museum: 0.5 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 14.5 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 24.1 miles
Learn More
Holiday Music Motel is the best budget hotel in Door County. Perhaps you need to learn more about the Holiday Music Motel.
Check Availability
If you’re ready to check availability for the Holiday Music Motel, don’t hesitate. And, don’t hesitate to make a booking if they have availability. Hotels book up months in advance in Door County, so act now before you lose your chance.
Best Door County Hotel on Lake Michigan: Gordon Lodge
Gordon Lodge offers something that no other hotel on this list does: a waterfront stay along the shore of Lake Michigan. Other hotels in this list are waterfront, but they are on Green Bay. Green Bay is great! But, there’s something special and majestic about Lake Michigan. It’s powerful and mysterious.
Gordon Lodge lets you experience all that in a gorgeous, park-like resort setting.
Gordon Lodge is great for:
- Families
- Groups
- Nature lovers
Gordon Lodge is set on 130 acres right on the shores of Lake Michigan. This is a great place to stay for nature lovers. Beautiful water views are abundant, and trails traverse the wooded landscape.
This is also an excellent location for families. Families will appreciate the cottages and vacation homes available. Being able to spread out into separate bedrooms and having the option to cook is a great benefit for families. The free breakfast will also be a plus for many families.
Gordon Lodge is not a great place if you want walkability. It is not close to offsite restaurants, shops, or attractions.
However, the onsite restaurant and activities mean that you may not even want to venture off the property some days.
Accommodations
Gordon Lodge has a wide array of lodging options available. Options include:
- King rooms
- Double rooms
- Queen studios
- Five-bedroom house
- Two-bedroom cottages
- One-bedroom cottages
Amenities
Facility amenities include:
- Waterfront
- Private beach
- Equipment rentals
- Outdoor pool
- Hot tub
- Restaurant
- Bar
- Nature trails
- Basketball court
- Tennis court
In-room amenities include:
- Free Wi-Fi
- Hair dryer
- Refrigerator
- Kitchen in some units
- Flat screen TV
Pros
- On Lake Michigan
- Park-like setting
- Free breakfast
- Lots of lodging options
Cons
- Not walkable
- Not pet-friendly
Location
One of the most defining features of Gordon Lodge is its location. Right on the shores of Lake Michigan and on a sprawling, wooded property, this is a great place for beautiful water views and connecting with nature.
However, Gordon Lodge is to itself and not in town. This is not a place to go if you want walkable access to offsite restaurants, shopping, and attractions.
Gordon Lodge is located at 1420 Pine Drive, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Baileys Harbor: 6.2 miles
- Cana Island Lighthouse: 4.5 miles
- Newport State Park: 17.5 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 17.6 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 8.1 miles
Learn More
Gordon Lodge is the best Door County hotel on Lake Michigan. However, perhaps you need to learn more about Gordon Lodge before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Gordon Lodge, do not hesitate. Lodging in Door County books up well in advance. Now is the time to act, before this property no longer has availability.
If you find a hotel that you like, do not hesitate to book it. Rooms in Door County fully book up in the prime tourist season, and many travelers book their accommodations a year in advance. Many properties offer free cancellations, so your risk is minimal in making a booking.
This page contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on the link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Every effort has been made to provide accurate information. However, information can change. Please verify important information directly with the property. Images not necessarily representative of the property.
Top 3 Picks
Cozy and pet-friendly hotel with a free breakfast.
Waterfront hotel with great facilities and beautiful sunsets.
Waterfront hotel with a private beach.
Best Door County Hotels Comparison Chart
All-Around Best Hotel: Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
Waterfront hotel with great facilities and beautiful sunsets.
Best Pet-friendly Hotel in Door County: Open Hearth Lodge
Cozy and pet-friendly hotel with a free breakfast.
Best Door County Hotel with a Private Beach: Bay Breeze Resort
Waterfront hotel in Ephraim with a private, sand beach.
Best Door County Hotel for Families: Pheasant Park Resort
Sister Bay resort with lots of amenities and spacious suites.
Best Door County Hotel for Winter: High Point Inn
Cozy hotel with fireplaces in every room that is open year-round.
Most Charming Hotel in Door County: The Water Street Inn
Charming, old-fashioned inn with a private beach.
Best Budget Hotel: Holiday Music Motel
Fun, quirky, and budget-friendly hotel in downtown Sturgeon Bay.
Search for More Door County Hotels
These are just a few of the great hotels in Door County. Maybe you want to explore a few more options beyond what we listed in this article. Use the search form to find the right Door County hotel for you:
More Information about Door County, WI
Door County is a peninsula and archipelago of islands jutting out into Lake Michigan on the east side of Wisconsin. It is known for its rugged beauty, gorgeous waterscapes, and quaint, nostalgic ambiance. It is one of the most popular vacation destinations in the Midwest and the United States.
Things To Do in Door County
If you are wondering if there will be enough to keep you occupied during a Door County vacation, don’t worry. We have you covered! Check out our posts on the best things to do in Door County to find the right activities for your group.
Door County Restaurants
From five-stars to dive-bars, Door County has a restaurant for you.. Check out our list of the best restaurants in Baileys Harbor to learn more about some of the best places to eat here.
What To Consider When Choosing a Door County Hotel
Give some careful thought when choosing a Door County hotel. Questions you should consider include:
- Is this hotel kid-friendly?
- Is this hotel pet-friendly?
- Which village or city do I want to stay in?
- Which body of water is this on?
- Do I want a private beach area?
- Does this hotel have daily housekeeping?
Is this hotel kid and pet friendly?
Some travel to bond with the family, including kids, grandkids, and even fido. Others are looking to get away from the kids and want a break from the noise and business that kids and pets bring along. Not all Door County hotels are kid and pet friendly. Some properties even have no-children policies! Make sure to research the property carefully.
Which village or city do I want to stay in?
Door County’s villages and cities each offer something unique to travelers. Some are located along Green Bay, others on Lake Michigan. Some have amenities like grocery stores, others do not. Some are great for shopping, while others are great for getting away from crowds.
Which Body of Water?
The most important matter to decide when picking a Door County hotel on the water is: “Which body of water do you want to stay on?”.
Hotels on Lake Michigan will offer cool breezes, gorgeous sunrises, and freedom from crowds. Locals call this the “quiet side” of Door County. If you are a morning coffee kind of person, you might like a hotel on Lake Michigan. On the other hand, most will not want to swim in these waters until later in the season when air and water temperatures rise.
Hotels on Green Bay offer beautiful sunsets and closer access to restaurants and other amenities. In addition, the water warms up quicker here, so you might be more likely to swim in Green Bay. If you are an evening cocktail sort of person rather than a morning coffee sort of person, you might like a hotel on the water of Green Bay. On the other hand, this is the busy side of Door County. You might encounter crowds here – great for those who like to see and be seen, but less than ideal for those who want more solitude.
Sturgeon Bay is a smaller bay off of Green Bay. Hotels on Sturgeon Bay will offer access to the amenities of the City of Sturgeon Bay, Door County’s only city.
Do I Want a Private Beach Area?
You might assume that a Door County hotel on the water has a beach area for swimming, but this is not necessarily the case. Some hotels do not offer a private beach area, even if they have a private shoreline. However, even if the hotel you choose does not have a private beach, Door County has many public beaches.
Does This Hotel Have Daily Housekeeping?
Many hotels in Door County have daily housekeeping, but many don’t. This is due to a couple of factors. First, given staffing difficulties over the last few years, many hotels across the country have eliminated daily housekeeping. Second, Door County has many condominium-style lodging options. Lots of these frequently do not have daily housekeeping. If this is important for you, make sure to verify that they have housekeeping.
Frequently Asked Questions about Door County Hotels
Pet-friendly hotels in Door County include:
– Open Hearth Lodge
– Country House Resort
– Holiday Music Motel
Family-friendly hotels in Door County include:
– Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
– Open Hearth Lodge
– Bay Breeze Resort
– Pheasant Park Resort
– High Point Inn
– Harbor Guest House
– The Water Street Inn
– Gordon Lodge
Door Count hotels with swimming pools include:
– Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
– Open Hearth Lodge
– Bay Breeze Resort
– Pheasant Park Resort
– Country House Resort
– High Point Inn
– The Water Street Inn
– Gordon Lodge
Door County hotels with water views include:
– Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort
– Bay Breeze Resort
– Country House Resort
– Harbor Guest House
– The Water Street Inn
– Gordon Lodge
