5 Best Restaurants In Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Over the last decade, Sister Bay has become the iconic village of Door County tourism. And, no wonder. Through decades of civic planning and work, Sister Bay has cultivated the best public waterfront access of any village in Door County. The waterfront is Sister Bay, and Sister Bay is the waterfront. It is fitting that Door County’s most iconic restaurant, you know, the one with goats on the roof, is in Sister Bay. But, this tiny village offers other great restaurants, too. This post will help you explore the best restaurants in Sister Bay, Wisconsin.

goat on a sod roof with the words "Sister Bay, WI Restaurants HelloDoorCounty.com"
Image Modified from “All Johnson’s Goat” by Eden, Janine and Jim via Flickr.com. Used by permission (CC BY 2.0).

5 Best Restaurants in Sister Bay, WI

Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant

It’s kitschy and touristy and busy, and we love it for all of this and more. Al Johnson’s is the iconic restaurant of Door County.

Even if you don’t dine at Al Johnson’s, you’ll want to stroll by to get a picture of the goats on the sod roof.

But, you probably should dine at Al Johnson’s.

Famous for their Swedish pancakes served with Swedish meatballs (Think of it as the Swedish equivalent of chicken and waffles.), Al Johnson’s offers a full breakfast and lunch menu daily.

Address: 10698 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234
Phone: 920-854-2626


This upscale Sister Bay restaurant is the best place to get a steak in Door County. Customers appreciate the clean, modern ambiance, the excellent service, the amazing views, and the high-quality food. Get a reservation, and try to get the outdoor, upstairs seating, which offers views over the Bay of Green Bay.

We rated Chop as the Best Place to Celebrate an Adult’s Birthday.

Phone: 920-854-2700
Address: 2345 Mill Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234

Grasse’s Grill

Grasse’s Grill boasts “comfort food with a modern twist.”

This is a favorite place to eat in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, both for the food quality, which is excellent, and also for the prices. Without sacrificing on the flavor or freshness, Grasse’s has some of the best prices in northern Door County.

You’ll leave Grasse’s satisfied.

Address: 10663 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234
Phone: 920-854-1125

Sister Bay Bowl

Billing itself “Your Go-To Bowling Hub and Supper Club,” Sister Bay Bowl is a third-generation family institution in Northern Door County. You can spend an entire afternoon and evening at Sister Bay Bowl. Bowl a few rounds in the late afternoon, have dinner in the supper club, and stay into the evening for their frequent live music concerts. The Sister Bay Bowl epitomizes the supper club quality of being a destination rather than a stop along the way in one’s evening.

Phone: 920-854-2841
Address: 10640 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234

Wild Tomato

Wild Tomato offers wood-fired pizza, salads, sandwiches, and burgers. Customers love the location of this restaurant right next to Sister Bay’s Waterfront Park. Eat in, or grab a pizza to go and head to a bench in the park overlooking Sister Bay, an inlet off of the bay of Green Bay. This is a great place to eat after spending some time on the beach.

Wild Tomato also has a location in Sister Bay.

Phone: 920-854-4685
Address: 10677 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234

More Information About Sister Bay, WI

Sister Bay has some great restaurants, but it is also a wonderful place to stay and play as well. Our post on the best things to do in Sister Bay will help you work up an appetite to eat at one of Sister Bay’s great restaurants. And, if you’re thinking about making Sister Bay the home base for your Door County vacation, our post on the best hotels in Sister Bay will help you find the perfect place to stay.