21 Best Restaurants In Sister Bay

Here are the best restaurants in Sister Bay, Door County, Wisconsin:

Embark on a culinary journey through Sister Bay, Wisconsin, where local flavors and unique dining experiences await. From traditional Swedish feasts to innovative American cuisine, discover the top establishments that make this charming town a food lover’s paradise.

Are you considering Sister Bay as your home base for a Door County vacation? Check out our article on Door County’s best hotels to find the best lodging for you.

goat on a sod roof with the words "Sister Bay, WI Restaurants HelloDoorCounty.com"
Image Modified from “All Johnson’s Goat” by Eden, Janine and Jim via Flickr.com. Used by permission (CC BY 2.0).

Sister Bay, Wisconsin Best Restaurants

Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant

Al Johnson's Sign

A visit to Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant is a journey into a blend of rich history, quirky charm, and delightful tastes. This iconic Sister Bay spot is renowned not just for its scrumptious Swedish cuisine but also for the unique sight of goats cheerfully grazing on the sod roof. Established by Al Johnson, a man with deep Swedish roots, and his wife Ingert, the restaurant offers an authentic Scandinavian experience. From the traditional décor to the waitresses in folk costumes and the annual “Roofing of the Goats Parade,” every detail adds to its allure. Embrace the kitsch, enjoy the goats, and savor every bite at this local gem.

Menu

Dive into authentic Swedish delights like the famed Swedish pancakes, meatballs paired with tangy lingonberries, or the hearty Pytt I Panna. Not just catering to Swedish tastes, the menu also includes American classics such as the Perch Plate and Hot Roast Beef Sandwich. The restaurant’s commitment to tradition is evident with every dish served on Porsgrund dishes, amidst interior adorned by renowned Norwegian artist Sigmund Arseth’s rosemaled painting.

Ambiance

Al Johnson’s offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, with a décor that transports you straight to a cozy Scandinavian cottage. The handcrafted log structure, meticulously built by Norwegian carpenters and adorned with a unique sod roof, radiates a rustic charm. Inside, the vibrant Scandinavian design, complete with a gift shop brimming with Nordic treasures, creates a welcoming space for diners.

Quick Facts

Whether you’re there for the delightful Swedish fare, the sight of goats on the roof, or the warm, friendly ambiance, Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant stands out as one of the best restaurants in Sister Bay. It’s a place where food, tradition, and fun meet, making every visit memorable.

Wild Tomato

wild tomato storefront sign

Nestled right between Hwy 42 and Sister Bay’s public beach, Wild Tomato is the perfect spot to unwind after a refreshing swim or a scenic hike. This family-friendly, casual restaurant has been serving up smiles and slices since its doors opened in 2014. Known for its wood-fired pizzas and a commitment to local, organic ingredients, it’s a hit with both locals and visitors. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese pizza or feeling adventurous with their unique specialty pies, Wild Tomato’s vibrant flavors and fun atmosphere are sure to please.

Menu

At Wild Tomato, the star of the show is undoubtedly their wood-fired pizzas, boasting a golden crust and a symphony of flavors. But there’s more! Their menu also features a tempting selection of salads, cheese curds, and a bread basket that’s perfect for sharing. With options catering to vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free diners, everyone leaves happy and full.

Ambiance

With an outdoor patio that invites you to relax and soak in the bustling Sister Bay vibe, Wild Tomato offers more than just great food. It’s a place where memories are made, laughs are shared, and the atmosphere buzzes with the energy of satisfied customers. The warm service and lively surroundings make it a go-to spot for anyone looking to enjoy a slice of Door County’s best.

Quick Facts

Wild Tomato isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience. It’s where the joy of a day spent outdoors meets the comfort of a meal cooked with care. A place where every bite tells a story of community, quality, and the simple pleasure of good food. Truly, it stands out among the best restaurants in Sister Bay.

Chop

storefront of Chop in Sister Bay, WI

After a day at Sister Bay Beach or exploring the state parks, Chop is the ideal place to satisfy your hunger with a touch of sophistication. Located in the heart of Sister Bay, Chop is celebrated for its classic American steakhouse vibe, offering the finest steaks, fresh local fish, and an impressive selection of wine and handcrafted cocktails. Whether you’re dining in the cozy interior or enjoying the stunning lake views from the rooftop dining area, Chop provides a dining experience that is both indulgent and unforgettable.

Menu

Chop’s menu is a testament to culinary excellence, featuring hand-cut certified Angus beef and fresh local seafood. The popovers, carrot cake, and chop salad are just a few of the favorites among patrons. For those looking for something special, the surf & turf with a starter of soup or salad is a popular choice. The menu caters to a range of dietary preferences, ensuring a memorable meal for every guest.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Chop is refined yet relaxed, making it perfect for both special occasions and casual outings. The display kitchen adds an interactive flair to your dining experience, while the seasonal outdoor seating offers picturesque views of the lake. The newly renovated Cellar and expanded rooftop dining area provide versatile spaces for private gatherings or simply enjoying a beautiful sunset.

Quick Facts

Chop stands as a beacon of fine dining in Sister Bay, offering an experience that blends the best of American steakhouse tradition with the unique charm of Door County. It’s more than a meal; it’s a celebration of quality, flavor, and the joy of good company.

Husby’s Food & Spirits

front of Husby's restaurant in Sturgeon Bay, Door County

Located in the heart of Sister Bay, Husby’s Food & Spirits is the go-to spot for sports enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With its friendly atmosphere and extensive menu, it’s the perfect place to gather with friends or family after an exciting day in Door County. Whether you’re in the mood for a heartwarming meal, a refreshing drink, or just want to catch the latest game on one of their 14 flatscreen TVs, Husby’s promises a vibrant and enjoyable experience.

Menu

Husby’s menu is a delightful mix of American favorites, ensuring there’s something for everyone. From the “Best Burger” as voted by Door County Magazine to homemade pizzas and the ever-popular Friday perch fry, every item is a hit. Don’t forget to check out their daily specials for something new, or indulge in their tasty soups and salads for a lighter option.

Ambiance

The Garage at Husby’s offers an open-air bar and grill that becomes a hub of excitement during the summer, featuring live music every weekend. The lively atmosphere, combined with the delicious food and an impressive selection of drinks, makes Husby’s a favorite among locals and visitors. Whether you’re here to enjoy the game, the music, or the company, you’re in for a good time.

Quick Facts

Husby’s Food & Spirits is more than just a restaurant; it’s a Sister Bay institution where great food, sports, and live music come together for an unforgettable experience. It’s the ideal spot to unwind and relish the best of Door County’s vibrant local scene.

Thyme

Elegant Dinner Setting Abstract Macro Background
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Thyme is a culinary gem just south of downtown Sister Bay, offering a celebration of life through food. This quaint establishment is a beacon for those seeking classic, casual cuisine crafted with the freshest, locally sourced ingredients. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch, dinner, or considering them for your next catering event, Thyme’s inviting atmosphere and inventive dishes are bound to make your experience memorable.

Menu

Thyme’s menu is a testament to culinary creativity and quality, featuring a range of dishes that cater to diverse tastes. From the heartwarming risotto to the meticulously prepared desserts, every dish is a work of art. The seasonal specials and classic favorites are prepared with care, ensuring a dining experience that’s both satisfying and sophisticated.

Ambiance

Set in a space that blends modern aesthetics with rustic charm, Thyme offers an ambiance that’s both welcoming and elegant. The open and casual interior, along with the beautiful outdoor dining area, creates the perfect backdrop for an intimate dinner or a relaxed evening with friends. The attention to detail in every corner speaks volumes about Thyme’s dedication to providing a unique and delightful dining experience.

Quick Facts

At Thyme, every meal is an opportunity to celebrate the rich flavors of life. This charming spot is a testament to the vibrant culinary scene of Door County and a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in a truly exceptional dining experience.

Crain’s Kitchen

soup bowl with soup in it
Via Unsplash. Used by permission (public domain).

For a unique blend of flavors and a casual dining experience, Crain’s Kitchen in Sister Bay is a delightful choice. Specializing in sandwiches crafted on fresh biscuits and a variety of homemade soups with a Southwestern twist, this eatery offers a cozy atmosphere where every meal feels like a comforting, homely experience. Whether you’re looking for a quick, light meal or a leisurely lunch, Crain’s Kitchen’s fresh, vibrant flavors are sure to impress.

Menu

Crain’s Kitchen prides itself on its fresh, homemade biscuits that form the base of their renowned sandwiches. Choose from fillings like roasted chicken, pork, and beef, all prepared daily to ensure the highest quality and taste. The menu also boasts a variety of soups, including tomato, chili, green chili, posole, and chicken soup, each bursting with robust flavors and perfect for any season.

Ambiance

Nestled next to On Deck Clothing and Lure, Crain’s Kitchen is a quaint spot with a welcoming vibe. The interior is tastefully decorated with subtle touches of purple and green, creating a fresh and inviting atmosphere. The outdoor seating area, adorned with metal chairs and tables, is perfect for enjoying your meal under the Sister Bay sky. Inside, the cute walk-up counter and open kitchen add to the casual, friendly ambiance.

Quick Facts

Crain’s Kitchen offers an intimate and laid-back dining experience, ideal for those looking to enjoy hearty, flavorful food in a relaxed setting. It’s a must-visit for both locals and visitors looking for a taste of Door County’s culinary diversity.

Zero Sum Door County

Beetroot, apple and celery juice.
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Nestled in the Country Walk Shops of Sister Bay, Zero Sum Door County is more than just a juice bar and breakfast café. It’s a pioneering venture that aims to operate with a zero environmental footprint, offering an array of fresh, local, and organic ingredients in every item on the menu. Zero Sum is a testament to sustainable living, delivering delicious food while supporting nature in Door County through various initiatives.

Menu

Zero Sum offers a health-conscious menu that caters to all dietary needs, entirely gluten-free and featuring options for vegans and dairy-free choices. Start your day energized with their signature S’Good Life muffin or waffle, or choose from their selection of fresh juices, smoothies made from organic fruits and local vegetables, and beautiful smoothie bowls. The quiche, made from scratch, and the freshly baked pastry add a delightful touch to your meal.

Ambiance

This quaint establishment, with its cozy interior and inviting outdoor seating, offers a warm, inviting atmosphere. It’s a place where guests can relax and enjoy their meal, knowing that they are part of something bigger – a movement towards a sustainable and healthy lifestyle. The décor, infused with subtle touches of nature and sustainability, echoes the ethos of Zero Sum Door County.

Quick Facts

Zero Sum Door County offers a unique culinary experience that nourishes the body and soul, embodying the essence of sustainable and mindful living. It’s a must-visit for those who cherish the harmony between great taste and environmental stewardship.

Fat Belly

sushi
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

If you are looking for sushi, ramen, or poke, Fat Belly is the place for you in Sister Bay. Whether you’re in for a quick lunch or a relaxing dinner, Fat Belly’s inviting outdoor seating area ensures a pleasant dining experience, with a trendy and casual atmosphere that makes every visit special.

Menu

Fat Belly is celebrated for its unique menu offerings. Burgers, steaks, and fried fish are common in Door County. Not so common are what Fat Belly offers: sushi, ramen, and poke bowls. If you’re looking to change it up, Fat Belly is the place.

Ambiance

Fat Belly stands out for its fast service and inviting ambiance. The outdoor seating area allows you to enjoy your meal in the heart of Sister Bay, making it an ideal spot for both solo dining and gatherings. The casual, trendy atmosphere makes it a popular choice among locals and visitors seeking a memorable dining experience.

Quick Facts

Fat Belly is more than just a restaurant; it’s a destination where good food meets a great atmosphere. With a focus on fresh ingredients and a commitment to satisfying a range of tastes, it’s a must-visit spot in Sister Bay for anyone looking to enjoy a meal crafted with care.

Skip Stone Coffee Roasters

coffee beans
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Skip Stone Coffee Roasters is not just a coffee shop; it’s a warm, welcoming corner in Sister Bay where the community and visitors come together. As part of the Wild Restaurant Concepts, Skip Stone prides itself on serving artisan coffee, freshly baked goods, and a variety of breakfast sandwiches in a cozy, inviting atmosphere.

Menu

The menu at Skip Stone Coffee Roasters features a delightful array of café classics, using roasted beans from Milwaukee’s Pilcrow Coffee. Patrons can savor everything from Lattes with house-made syrups, rich in flavor and not overly sweet, to freshly baked apple crumble and orange cranberry muffins. The food menu is enhanced with the addition of diverse breakfast sandwiches, catering to various palates.

Ambiance

Skip Stone Coffee Roasters underwent a summer of remodeling, transforming from a T-shirt store into a vibrant space with bold red chandeliers, rustic barn board accents, and black-and-white patterned tile flooring. The café boasts a loft area with couches and multiple tables overlooking the bay, making it a perfect spot to unwind with a cup of coffee and a delicious treat.

Quick Facts

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Skip Stone Coffee Roasters offers a memorable experience with its excellent coffee, delicious baked goods, and the charming ambiance of a true Door County establishment.

Waterfront Restaurant

sunset over the bay of Green Bay in Door County, Wisconsin.
Via Hello Door County

Waterfront Restaurant in Door County offers a unique dining experience right on the shores of Green Bay. With every table offering a stunning view of the sunset, this place is a gem in Sister Bay. Contrary to what you might expect, waterfront dining is surprisingly hard to find in Door County, making Waterfront Restaurant a rare treat. Their menu changes seasonally, often nightly, to reflect the freshest local ingredients.

Menu

Waterfront’s menu is a delightful mix of local and seasonal flavors, changing regularly to offer the freshest options. From seafood to vegetarian dishes, there’s something for everyone. Their commitment to using local ingredients ensures that each dish is a reflection of Door County’s rich culinary landscape.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Waterfront Restaurant is all about elegant comfort with a scenic backdrop. The interior exudes a warm, welcoming feel, matched with the breathtaking views of Green Bay. It’s the perfect setting for a romantic dinner or a special family gathering, where the beauty of Door County enhances your dining experience.

Quick Facts

Alexander’s

sign for Alexander's restaurant

Alexander’s of Door County offers a contemporary take on the classic Wisconsin supper club, blending traditional charm with modern elegance. Located in Fish Creek, Door County, Wisconsin, Alexander’s is renowned for its cozy yet classy atmosphere, exquisite entrees, and in-house-made desserts. It’s the perfect place to indulge in a fine dining experience that captures the essence of Wisconsin’s culinary traditions.

Menu

The menu at Alexander’s is a celebration of flavors and finesse. Entrees are served with potato and vegetable du jour, a choice of house salad or cup of homemade soup, and fresh baked bread and butter. Favorites include Stuffed Pork Chop, Chicken Alexander, Shrimp Carbonara, New York Strip, BBQ Salmon, and Roasted Cherry Duck. The appetizers, like Shrimp Tempura and Oysters Rockefeller, set the stage for an unforgettable meal. And for dessert, the in-house-made treats like the Chocolate Peanut Butter Torte and Key Lime Pie are not to be missed.

Ambiance

Alexander’s atmosphere is described as “cozy yet classy,” making it a perfect spot for a special night out. The testimonials from customers highlight the warm, welcoming environment and the attentive, friendly service. Whether you’re there for a casual meal or a special occasion, Alexander’s ensures a dining experience that’s both comfortable and refined.

Quick Facts

At Alexander’s, every meal is an opportunity to savor the best of Door County’s culinary offerings, served with care and sophistication. It’s a destination where the tradition of the supper club is reimagined and brought to life with a modern twist.

The Garage at Husby’s

Filling Station and Garage at Husby's.

The Garage at Husby’s in Sister Bay brings a splash of unique flavor to Door County, with its blend of Mexican and American cuisine.

Menu

The Garage offers a menu that perfectly blends quick and tasty Mexican and American cuisine. It’s well-known for local whitefish tacos and a range of other mouth-watering options. With cold beer, wine, cocktails, and daily drink specials, it’s the perfect spot to refuel your Door County adventure and kick back in the summer sun.

Ambiance

The Garage at Husby’s brings a historical touch to modern dining. It’s an extension of the Garage Bar, located in a tiny building that once served as a filling station. The owners have restored the building to its former glory, making it a unique spot that may just be “the smallest bar in Wisconsin”. With glass garage doors and a covered patio, The Garage merges history with contemporary comfort, making it an ideal spot to enjoy live music every weekend in season.

Quick Facts

The Garage at Husby’s is more than a dining venue; it’s a historical landmark and a vibrant part of the Sister Bay community. Whether you’re there for the best burgers, the live music, or to soak in the unique ambiance, The Garage at Husby’s is a must-visit destination in Door County.

Grasse’s Grill

cheeseburger

Positioned in the vibrant heart of Sister Bay, Grasse’s Grill stands out as a culinary highlight. Celebrating 12 years of operation, this chef-owned spot offers a unique mix of comfort food with a contemporary flair. It’s a place where quality meets creativity, securing its spot among the top eateries in Sister Bay.

Menu

Grasse’s Grill is a haven for food lovers, with a menu that celebrates local flavors and chef-driven craftsmanship. Indulge in their gourmet burgers, explore the vegetarian selections, or enjoy the beloved Nana’s Mac n’ Cheese. Their dedication to fresh, locally-sourced ingredients ensures every meal is a nod to Wisconsin’s rich culinary heritage.

Ambiance

Grasse’s Grill offers a relaxed and welcoming setting, with both indoor and outdoor seating, where guests feel immediately at home. It’s not just a meal; it’s an immersive experience where community warmth and culinary delight come together.

Quick Facts

Every visit to Grasse’s Grill, from the warm welcome by the Grasse family to the last sip of your craft beer, is about celebrating the joy of life and the art of good food.

Carroll House Restaurant

cheeseburger
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Carroll House Restaurant, a family-operated diner since 1957, is a cornerstone of comfort food in Sister Bay. Renowned for their Old Fashioned Waffles and friendly atmosphere, it’s a place where both locals and visitors feel right at home, making it a top contender among the best restaurants in Sister Bay.

Menu

Carroll House’s menu is a delightful journey through classic American breakfast and lunch. Their famous waffles, hearty omelettes, and cherry stuffed waffles are just the beginning. Every dish, made with care and served with a smile, reflects the restaurant’s commitment to quality and community.

Ambiance

Stepping into Carroll House is like entering a cozy time capsule. The diner’s nostalgic charm invites you to unwind and relish the simple pleasures of a good meal. It’s not just a restaurant; it’s a Sister Bay tradition where every visit feels like coming home.

Quick Facts

Carroll House is more than just a diner; it’s a warm, welcoming spot where each meal is served with a side of cherished memories and the promise of new ones to be made.

Stabbur Beer Garden

stabbur beer garden at Al Johnson's

Stabbur Beer Garden at Al Johnson’s in Sister Bay is a lively, open-air sanctuary for beer enthusiasts and casual diners alike. With its unique selection of 20 draft beers focusing on Wisconsin craft brews and hand-crafted specialty cocktails, Stabbur offers a vibrant atmosphere complemented by engaging lawn games and pet-friendly spaces, making it a standout in the Sister Bay dining scene.

Menu

The menu at Stabbur Beer Garden boasts a variety of bar-friendly foods and a constantly changing roster of draft beers. Whether you’re in the mood for a light snack or a fulfilling meal, the options are designed to pair perfectly with their extensive drink selections, ensuring a satisfying experience for every guest.

Ambiance

This beer garden is a blend of rustic charm and modern comfort. Constructed from Norwegian logs and featuring picnic tables under the trees, it provides a relaxed setting where you can unwind, enjoy the games, and socialize. The HD TV displays add a contemporary touch, perfect for catching a game while you’re there.

Quick Facts

Stabbur Beer Garden is where the essence of Sister Bay’s social and culinary life comes together, offering an experience that’s as refreshing as the beers they serve.

Dovetail Bar & Grill

Golden delicious batter fried fish with french fries, tartar sauce, coleslaw, and ketchup.
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Dovetail Bar & Grill offers a unique twist on classic American Bar & Grill cuisine with a Door County flavor. Owned by the career-waiter Terry Wurster and his wife Linda Hedeen-Wurster, this welcoming spot is known for its inviting atmosphere, extensive beer and wine selection, and hearty, feel-good meals.

Menu

The menu at Dovetail Bar & Grill is a delightful showcase of American pub-style favorites with a local touch. From scrumptious appetizers and hearty sandwiches to vegetarian fare and indulgent desserts, there’s something to satisfy every palate. Favorites like whitefish tacos highlight the local flavors.

Ambiance

Dovetail Bar & Grill offers a cozy and casual dining experience, perfect for a laid-back meal with friends or family. The interior is as inviting as the menu, with a comfortable setting that makes you feel right at home.

Quick Facts

Whether you’re a Sister Bay local or just passing through, Dovetail Bar & Grill is a must-visit for its warm hospitality, delicious food, and the authentic Door County dining experience.

Twelve Eleven Wine Bar + Provisions

Friends clinking wine glasses
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Nestled in the heart of Sister Bay, Twelve Eleven Wine Bar + Provisions offers a sophisticated yet cozy retreat for wine lovers. Collaborating with Thyme Cuisine, this full-service restaurant, wine bar, and provisions shop is a true gem, featuring indoor and outdoor dining, private events, and a meticulously curated selection of wines and artisanal fare.

Menu

Twelve Eleven’s provisions shop presents an exquisite range of wine selections from their namesake and two additional California-based labels, crafted by winemakers from Wisconsin and Michigan. The shop also boasts a selection of artisanal cheeses, charcuterie, bread, and local wares, perfect for creating your own personalized charcuterie board.

Ambiance

With its chic decor and inviting atmosphere, Twelve Eleven offers the perfect setting for unwinding with a glass of wine. The outdoor patio, complemented by fire pits and blankets to keep you warm, provides a serene backdrop for live music events and social gatherings.

Quick Facts

Twelve Eleven Wine Bar + Provisions is not just a dining destination; it’s an experience, where every detail is carefully crafted to ensure a memorable visit.

Door County Creamery

exterior of Door County Creamery

Door County Creamery is a delightful escape into the world of artisan cheeses and dairy delights. This creamery and café is a favorite among locals and visitors alike, offering a unique farm-to-table experience with a range of handcrafted goat cheeses, gelato, and farm-fresh cuisine.

Menu

The menu at Door County Creamery is a testament to the rich dairy heritage of the region. Enjoy a selection of freshly made goat cheeses, sumptuous sandwiches, and salads featuring ingredients sourced directly from their farm. Don’t miss their famous gelato, a perfect treat to sweeten your day.

Ambiance

Situated in the charming town of Sister Bay, the creamery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere. The café’s rustic decor and cozy seating create the perfect setting to enjoy a leisurely meal or a quick snack. Whether you’re here to savor their cheeses or sip on a freshly brewed coffee, the ambiance is sure to make your visit a memorable one.

Quick Facts

Door County Creamery is not just a place to eat; it’s a destination where you can immerse yourself in the local culture and savor the authentic tastes of Door County.

Sister Bay Bowl

exterior of Sister Bay Bowl

Sister Bay Bowl is not just a bowling alley; it’s an iconic supper club and a cherished part of Sister Bay’s history. Since its beginnings in 1958, it has been the go-to spot for locals and tourists alike, offering an unbeatable combination of good food, fun, and community spirit.

Menu

Sister Bay Bowl is famous for its “Best Fish Fry” and “Best Old Fashioned,” according to local voters. While known for their lightly floured perch, tender prime rib, perfectly prepared steaks, broasted chicken, and slow-cooked ribs, the menu also offers lighter options like sandwiches, salads, and soups. And for the little ones, the kids’ menu includes a game of bowling, making it a hit among families.

Ambiance

Step into Sister Bay Bowl, and you’re stepping into a piece of Door County’s history. The vintage lanes, cozy bar, and friendly atmosphere make it the perfect place for a date night, family dinner, or a fun evening with friends. The bowling alley is complemented by an outdoor Alley Bar, offering views of downtown Sister Bay, making it an ideal spot for private events.

Quick Facts

Sister Bay Bowl is more than a restaurant or a bowling alley; it’s a tradition. With its commitment to serving delicious meals and creating a space where everyone feels welcome, it’s a place where memories are made and cherished for years to come.

Fred & Fuzzy’s Waterfront Bar & Grill

Fred & Fuzzy’s Waterfront Bar & Grill offers a slice of paradise in Sister Bay, combining the relaxed vibe of a tiki bar with the stunning beauty of Little Sister Bay. This Northwoods-style retreat is known for its open grill delights, refreshing drinks, and a casual atmosphere that captures the essence of Door County’s lakeside living.

Menu

The menu at Fred & Fuzzy’s is centered around the grill, serving up delicious burgers, whitefish sandwiches, and vegetarian delights like the portabella mushroom and three-cheese deluxe sandwiches. Not to be missed are the panini sandwiches grilled on ciabatta bread and the Little Sister Famous Smoked Fish Pate, a secret recipe of smoked whitefish. Their Fish Fry on Wednesdays and Fridays, featuring fresh lake perch, has quickly become a tradition.

Ambiance

Fred & Fuzzy’s is the perfect escape, located just off the beaten path. Its large dock, scenic views of clear waters, and children playing on the beach create a picturesque backdrop. The indoor and outdoor seating areas provide comfortable spaces to enjoy meals, while the live music series adds to the laid-back atmosphere. Whether you’re savoring a sunset cocktail or indulging in an afternoon snack, Fred & Fuzzy’s ensures every visit is memorable.

Quick Facts

From the delicious smells of the grill to the soothing sounds of the waves and live music, Fred & Fuzzy’s is not just a dining spot but a destination where you can relax and immerse yourself in the joy of lakeside dining.

Lure Restaurant

chef holding plate of food at a restaurant in Door County
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Lure Restaurant in Sister Bay offers a unique Door County dining experience, combining casual fine dining with a diverse menu. Known for its small plates, sushi, fresh fish and seafood, hand-cut steaks, and artisan cocktails, Lure provides an atmosphere that’s both sophisticated and welcoming.

Menu

The menu at Lure is a celebration of local and international flavors, featuring an array of small plates, freshly prepared sushi, seafood dishes, and hand-cut steaks. Their cocktail menu includes traditional favorites and inventive new concoctions, ensuring that there’s something to satisfy every palate.

Ambiance

Lure’s newly remodeled space invites guests to enjoy their meals in a variety of settings, from the beautiful garden patio and covered porch to intimate booths. The restaurant also offers private dining for groups of 20 or more, making it an ideal location for special occasions and business meetings.

Quick Facts

Whether you’re looking for a place to enjoy a romantic dinner, a family meal, or a gathering with friends, Lure Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone seeking top-notch food and a memorable dining experience in Door County.

Family-Friendly Restaurants in Sister Bay

family dining at a waterfront restaurant

Sister Bay is not only known for its scenic beauty but also for its family-friendly dining options. Here are some top picks where the whole family can enjoy a delicious meal together:

  • Al Johnson’s: A unique and unforgettable experience awaits at Al Johnson’s, where you can enjoy authentic Swedish cuisine. The restaurant is famous for its grassy rooftop where goats graze, providing entertainment for the whole family.
  • Husby’s: Known as a place where you can relax and enjoy a good meal in a casual setting. Husby’s offers a variety of dishes that cater to all ages, making it a perfect spot for families looking to unwind.
  • Grasse’s Grill: Offers a welcoming atmosphere and a menu that emphasizes local ingredients and homemade meals. Their diverse menu has something for everyone, from gourmet burgers to fresh salads and Nana’s Mac n’ Cheese.
  • Sister Bay Bowl: A fun spot not just for a meal but also for entertainment. Enjoy classic American cuisine and then hit the lanes for some bowling fun with the family.

Each of these restaurants provides not only a great meal but also a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for families looking to make the most of their time in Sister Bay.

Pet-friendly Restaurants in Sister Bay

Sister Bay welcomes dogs and their owners with open arms and delicious dishes. Here’s a list of pet-friendly eateries where your furry friends can join you for a meal. Remember, it’s always a good idea to call ahead to confirm pet-friendly accommodations.

  • The Summer Kitchen Restaurant: A cozy café offering American cuisine with outdoor seating for you and your dog.
  • Stabbur Beer Garden at Al Johnson’s: A spacious, dog-friendly Swedish beer garden perfect for sipping cold beers with your furry companion.
  • Carroll House Restaurant: Enjoy breakfast or lunch on the shaded back patio with your pooch by your side.
  • Grasse’s Grill: A seasonal spot with gourmet burgers, salads, and vegetarian items, welcoming dogs at their outdoor tables.
  • The Patio and Kitschinn: Offers smoothies, juices, burgers, and sandwiches, with a spacious patio where leashed dogs are welcome.
  • LURE Restaurant: A high-end eatery serving delicious seafood with pet-friendly outdoor tables.
  • Door County Ice Cream Factory & Sandwich Shoppe: A casual joint with a variety of tasty treats and outdoor tables for you and your dog.
  • Door County Creamery: Seasonal establishment offering frozen treats, sandwiches, and cheeses with outdoor tables for leashed pups.
  • The Garage at Husby’s: Features American and Mexican-inspired eats and a dog-friendly outdoor area.
  • CHOP Restaurant: Celebrated for its great steak and pet-friendly atmosphere, located next to the new Dorr Hotel.

Remember, when planning a meal out with your dog in Sister Bay, a quick call to the restaurant can ensure that you and your furry friend have the best experience possible.

Tips for Dining in Sister Bay, Door County, WI

Restaurant table set for dinner in front of water with the sun setting. Superimposed text says: Best Restaurants Sister Bay, WI; HelloDoorCounty.com."

When heading out for a meal in the picturesque Sister Bay, a little preparation can make your dining experience smooth and enjoyable. Here are some tips to keep in mind:

  • Verify Hours: Always call ahead to confirm hours. Restaurants in Door County can have unpredictable schedules, especially outside of peak seasons.
  • Make Reservations: Secure a spot in advance. During the prime tourist season, Door County’s best eateries are often full, so it’s wise to reserve your table early.
  • Be Flexible: Be ready for plan B. Full restaurants and changing hours might mean last-minute adjustments to your dining plans.
  • Check for Seasonal Specials: Many restaurants in Sister Bay offer seasonal dishes or specials. Make sure to ask about these unique offerings to enjoy what’s fresh and in season.
  • Consider Off-Peak Dining: To avoid crowds, consider dining during off-peak hours. Enjoying a late lunch or an early dinner can mean a quieter atmosphere and potentially faster service.
  • Explore Local Cuisine: Don’t miss out on the local specialties. Sister Bay offers a variety of dishes unique to the area, so be adventurous and try something new.
  • Mind Parking: Especially during busy times, parking can be a challenge. Allow extra time to find parking, or consider walking or biking if you’re staying nearby.
  • Dress Appropriately: Weather in Door County can be variable. Check the forecast and dress in layers, so you’re comfortable dining indoors or out.

With these tips in mind, you’re set for a fantastic culinary adventure in Sister Bay!

Local Specialties and Must-Try Dishes in Sister Bay, WI

Restaurant table set for dinner in front of water with the sun setting. Superimposed text says: Best Restaurants Sister Bay, WI; HelloDoorCounty.com."

Sister Bay is not just about picturesque views and cozy dining spots; it’s a haven for food lovers with its unique local specialties. When you’re in town, don’t miss out on these must-try dishes:

  • Swedish Fare at Al Johnson’s: Experience authentic Swedish cuisine, complete with Swedish pancakes and lingonberries, in this iconic restaurant known for its grass-roofed building and roaming goats.
  • Fish Boils: A traditional Door County treat, fish boils are a spectacular way to enjoy freshly caught whitefish cooked in a large kettle with potatoes and onions, served with melted butter and lemon.
  • Friday Fish Fries: A Wisconsin tradition, indulge in a hearty fish fry available at many local eateries. It’s the perfect way to kick off your weekend.
  • Cherry Pie: Door County is famous for its cherries, and there’s no better way to savor them than in a delicious, homemade cherry pie, bursting with local fruit.
  • Door County Whitefish: Whether it’s smoked, grilled, or pan-fried, the local whitefish is a must-try for seafood enthusiasts.
  • Bratwurst: Savor this German-inspired local favorite, often served grilled with a side of sauerkraut and mustard.
  • Cheese Curds: No visit to Wisconsin is complete without trying freshly made cheese curds, best enjoyed warm and with a side of ranch dressing.
  • Local Craft Beers and Ciders: Pair your meal with a pint of local craft beer or cider, perfect for sipping as you enjoy the beautiful Sister Bay scenery.
  • Traditional Door County Supper Clubs: Supper clubs are places to linger for the evening, not a place to dine and dash. Experience traditional hospitality at these classic dining institutions.

Each dish offers a taste of the local culture and traditions, making your dining experience in Sister Bay truly unforgettable.

Food in Sister Bay

Sister Bay’s food scene is a vibrant mosaic of flavors, presenting a delightful mix of traditional and contemporary cuisine. It’s a place where the aroma of freshly baked Swedish pastries intertwines with the sizzle of gourmet American steaks and the warmth of intimate, locally-owned eateries. Here, every meal is a celebration of community and culinary craftsmanship.

More About Sister Bay

These Sister Bay Restaurants are great places to start the day or to refuel after exploring and adventuring. Sister Bay has lots to offer, both as a place to stay and as a place to play. Make sure to check out our articles on the best things to do in Sister Bay and the best hotels in Sister Bay to dive deeper into this great location.

More Door County Restaurant Roundups

If you’re looking for a restaurant in Door County, we have lots of other content to help you find the perfect eatery for you. Check out our other restaurant roundup reviews:

Culinary Conclusion – Sister Bay’s Best Restuarants

In Sister Bay, every restaurant tells a story, offering not just meals but experiences to cherish. Embrace the town’s diverse culinary scene, where the warmth of local hospitality and the richness of flavors promise to make every dining adventure memorable.

About the author
Mark Stoneman
Hi! My name is Mark! I have been a resident of Door County for almost ten years now, and I'm glad to help you say "Hello" to Door County. I believe that travel helps to change lives, and because of that, I want to help you improve your life through travel.