5 Best Hotels in Fish Creek, WI (with photos)

Many travelers consider Fish Creek in Door County, Wisconsin to be one of the most memorable places they have ever visited. Unfortunately, finding accommodations in Fish Creek can be difficult. Since the hotels in Fish Creek are mostly privately owned, not chain hotels, you aren’t quite sure what the property is like. As Door County locals, we at HelloDoorCounty.com can help you decide which hotel is best for you. Here is a list of the 5 best hotels in Fish Creek, Wisconsin.

collage of hotel room, sunset, front of Julie's Park Cafe and Motel, sail boat. Text: Hotels Fish Creek WI

This page contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on the link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission. This helps us provide content to help you plan life-changing travel experiences. Thanks!

Summary

This post will cover the best hotels in Fish Creek in Door County, WI, including:

In addition, make sure to scroll to the end of the article for more great info, including:

If you find a hotel that you like, do not hesitate to book it. Rooms in Door County fully book up in the prime tourist season, and many travelers book their accommodations a year in advance. Many properties offer free cancellations, so your risk is minimal in making a booking.

Fish Creek Hotel Comparison Table

The Homestead Suites sign.

Best All-around Hotel:
Homestead Suites

✔ Family friendly
✔ Suites
✔ Indoor pool
✔ Indoor hot tub
✔ Sauna
✔ Outdoor pool
✔ Outdoor hot tub
✔ Gym
✔ Walkable
❌ Pet Friendly
❌ Waterfront

white building. Julie's Park Café & Motel, Fish Creek, Door County, WI
Via Hello Door County.

Best Budget Hotel:
Julie’s Park Café & Motel

✔ Family Friendly
✔ Suites
✔ Pet friendly
✔ Walkable
❌ Pool
❌ Hot Tub
❌ Sauna
❌ Waterfront

Via Hello Door County.

Best Waterfront Hotel:
Harbor Guest House

✔ Family Friendly
✔ Suites
✔ Waterfront
✔ Walkable
❌ Pool
❌ Hot Tub
❌ Sauna
❌ Pet Friendly

hotel bed
Via Hello Door County.

Best Walkable Hotel:
Main Street Motel

✔ Family Friendly
✔ Walkable
❌ Pool
❌ Hot Tub
❌ Sauna
❌ Pet Friendly
❌ Suites
❌ Waterfront

sun shining in a hotel room window

Best Hotel to Escape Crowds:
Peninsula Park-View Resort

✔ Family friendly
✔ Pet friendly
✔ Suites
✔ Outdoor pool
❌ Sauna
❌ Walkable
❌ Suites
❌ Waterfront

5 Best Hotels in Fish Creek, WI

All-Around Best Hotel in Fish Creek, WI: Homestead Suites

The Homestead Suites sign.

The all-around best hotel in Fish Creek, WI is Homestead Suites. We selected Homestead suites as the best all-around hotel due to its walkability within the village of Fish Creek, its amenities, and the variety of accommodations it offers to suit travelers with various lodging needs.

Homestead Suites is great for:

  • Outdoors enthusiasts
  • Families
  • Couples
  • Walkability

Accomodations

Homestead Suites offers the following types of accommodations:

  • Furnished suites
  • Vacation condos
  • Hotel rooms

Amenities

In-room amenities vary based on the type of lodging, so review your accommodation selections carefully if there are certain amenities you want. Across the various accommodation types, Homestead Suites offer the following in-room amenities:

  • Wi-Fi
  • Cable TV
  • Whirlpool tubs
  • Patios, decks, and balconies
  • Refrigerator
  • Microwave
  • Coffee Maker
  • Wet bar sinks
  • Fully equipped kitchens
  • Grills
  • Fireplaces

Facility amenities include:

  • Indoor pool
  • Indoor whirlpool
  • Sauna
  • Outdoor pool
  • Outdoor whirlpool
  • Bicycle and ski storage
  • Conference room
  • Game room
  • Gym
  • Guest laundry
  • Library

Location

Homestead Suites is located at 4006 Main St., Fish Creek, Wi 54212. This is on the east side of Fish Creek and is a walkable location to many attractions in Fish Creek like Peninsula State Park, restaurants, and fish boils.

A huge draw for Homestead Suites is its great location. Located right at the entrance to Peninsula State Park, this hotel is a great home base to explore Wisconsin’s most popular state park. Incredible adventures await in Peninsula State Park, including hiking, swimming, fishing, kayaking, historical tours, golfing, and more.

Nearby Attractions

  • Downtown Fish Creek: 0.5 miles
  • Fish Creek Beach: 0.4 miles
  • Cave Point County Park: 16.1 miles
  • Cana Island Light House: 13.9 miles
  • Peninsula State Park: 0.3 miles

Learn More

Homestead Suites is the best all-around hotel in beautiful Fish Creek, WI. Families and outdoors enthusiasts will love this property with lots of amenities. Perhaps you need to learn more about Homestead Suites before booking.

Check Availability

But, if you are interested in checking availability for Homestead Suites, do not hesitate. Lodging in Fish Creek and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.

Best Budget Hotel in Fish Creek, WI: Julie’s Park Café & Motel

white building. Julie's Park Café & Motel, Fish Creek, Door County, WI
Via Hello Door County.

The best budget Egg Harbor hotel is Julie’s Park Café & Motel. Julie’s Park Café & Motel is just a few miles north of Egg Harbor, near the entrance to Peninsula State Park.

Julie’s Park Café & Motel is great for:

  • Thriftsters
  • Outdoors enthusiasts
  • Families
  • Couples
  • Walkability
  • Pet-lovers

Accommodations

Julie’s Park Café & Motel offers the following room types:

  • 1 king
  • 1 king with whirlpool tub
  • 2 queens. Some queen rooms have sofa sleepers.
  • Suite. 2 bedrooms. 3 queen beds with a sofa sleeper. 2 bathrooms. Kitchen, dining area, living room. Sleeps 8.
  • Pet-friendly rooms

This is a two-story property with no elevator. Those who need a first-floor room should contact the property to book.

Amenities

In-room amenities include:

  • Pet-friendly rooms
  • Whirlpool tub rooms
  • Free Wi-Fi.
  • VOLO tablets

Facility amenities include:

  • Grassy courtyard with outdoor furniture and games.
  • Onsite restaurant
grassy area with lawn furniture.
Courtyard at Julie’s Park Café & Motel. Via Hello Door County.

Location

A huge draw for Julie’s Park Café & Motel is its great location. Located right at the entrance to Peninsula State Park, this hotel is a great home base to explore Wisconsin’s most popular state park. Incredible adventures await in Peninsula State Park, including hiking, swimming, fishing, kayaking, historical tours, golfing, and more.

Nearby Attractions

  • Downtown Fish Creek: 0.1 miles
  • Fish Creek Beach: 0.4 miles
  • Cave Point County Park: 16.1 miles
  • Cana Island Light House: 13.9 miles
  • Peninsula State Park: 0.1 miles

Learn More

Julie’s Park Café & Motel is the best budget hotel for beautiful Fish Creek, WI. Families and pet-lovers will love this property with lots of amenities. Perhaps you need to learn more about Julie’s Park Café & Motel before booking.

Check Availability

But, if you are interested in checking availability for Julie’s Park Café & Motel, do not hesitate. Lodging in Fish Creek and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.

Best Waterfront Hotel in Fish Creek, WI: Harbor Guest House

The best waterfront hotel in Fish Creek is Harbor Guest House. Harbor Guest House is right on Eagle Harbor. This is the place to stay if you want to see amazing sunsets over the bay of Green Bay right from your place of lodging.

Harbor Guest House also has a private marina with transient slips for boaters looking for lodging. Exit your hotel and get right in your boat to spend the day on the water.

Harbor Guest House is great for:

  • Couples
  • Families
  • Boaters

Accommodations

Harbor Guest House offers the following accommodation types:

  • One-bedroom condo suites
  • Two-bedroom condo suites

All suites have a full kitchen, living room, balcony or patio, fireplace, and water views.

Amenities

In-room amenities include:

  • Waterfront views
  • Full kitchen
  • Living room
  • Fireplace
  • Balcony or patio
  • Wi-Fi

Facility amenities include:

  • Grill
  • Marina with transient boat slips
  • Fire pit
  • Bike rental

Location

Right on the shore of Eagle Harbor in the bay of Green Bay, Harbor Guest House has one of the best locations of any hotel in Door County. 

Nearby Attractions

  • Downtown Fish Creek: 0.2 miles
  • Fish Creek Beach: 0.4 miles
  • Cave Point County Park: 16.9 miles
  • Cana Island Light House: 14.7 miles
  • Peninsula State Park: 0.9 miles

Learn More

Harbor Guest House is the best waterfront hotel in beautiful Fish Creek, WI. Families and outdoors enthusiasts will love this property with lots of amenities. Perhaps you need to learn more about Harbor Guest House before booking.

Check Availability

But, if you are interested in checking availability for Harbor Guest House, do not hesitate. Lodging in Fish Creek and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.

Best Walkable Hotel in Fish Creek, WI: Main Street Motel

hotel bed

The best hotel in Fish Creek for walkability is Main Street Motel. Main Street Motel is located in the heart of Fish Creek, WI. This is the historic area of Fish Creek, a place of charming white clap-board buildings, shady, mature trees, and access to Fish Creek’s Sunset Park.

This is an extremely walkable area, with lots of restaurants, bars, shopping, and parks available within an easy stroll.

Main Street Motel is great for:

  • Couples
  • Walkability

Accommodations

Main Street Motel offers the following accommodations:

  • One queen rooms
  • Two queen rooms
  • One king rooms

Guests should know that this is a two-story property without an elevator. Those who desire a first-floor room should request one at the time of booking.

Amenities

Main Street Motel offers the following in-room amenities:

  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Minirefrigerator, microwave, coffee maker
  • Cable TV

Main Street Motel offers the following property amenities:

  • Complementary EV charging stations
  • A beautiful courtyard garden with lounge furniture

Location

Main Street Motel is located in the heart of the historic district in Fish Creek, WI. This area is known for charming, white-clapboard buildings, mature, shady trees, beautiful parks, sunsets, and walkability to numerous restaurants, galleries, bars, and boutiques.

Nearby Attractions

  • Downtown Fish Creek: 0.1 miles
  • Fish Creek Beach: 0.4 miles
  • Cave Point County Park: 16.9 miles
  • Cana Island Light House: 14.7 miles
  • Peninsula State Park: 0.9 miles

Learn More

Main Street Motel is the best walkable hotel in beautiful Fish Creek, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about Main Street Motel before booking.

Check Availability

But, if you are interested in checking availability for Main Street Motel, do not hesitate. Lodging in Fish Creek and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.

Best Fish Creek Hotel to Escape the Crowds: Peninsula Park-View Resort

sun shining in a hotel room window

Sometimes you want to be right at the center of it all, and sometimes you want to get away. The Peninsula Park-View Resort is the best hotel in Fish Creek to escape the crowds. Located outside of the village of Fish Creek and next to Peninsula State Park, those who want a more relaxed, pastoral setting will enjoy Peninsula Park-View Resort

Peninsula Park-View Resort is great for:

  • Families
  • Pet-lovers
  • Outdoors enthusiasts

Accommodations

Peninsula Park-View Resort offers the following accommodations:

  • Queen Rooms
  • Double Queen Rooms
  • Family Suites
  • Cottages
  • Pet-friendly rooms

Amenities

In-room amenities vary depending on the type of accommodations, including:

  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Kitchens/Kitchenettes
  • Refrigerators
  • Microwaves

Property amenities include:

  • Outdoor pool
  • Complementary bicycle rental
  • Game room

Location

Peninsula Park-View Resort is located at 3397 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212. This is approximately 3 miles east of downtown Fish Creek. This is out in the country, and directly across the road from the middle entrance to Peninsula State Park.

Nearby Attractions

  • Downtown Fish Creek: 3.0 miles
  • Fish Creek Beach: 2.8 miles
  • Cave Point County Park: 15.8 miles
  • Cana Island Light House: 12.1 miles
  • Peninsula State Park: 0.1 miles

Learn More

Main Street Motel is the best walkable hotel in beautiful Fish Creek, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about Peninsula Park-View Resort before booking.

Check Availability

But, if you are interested in checking availability for Peninsula Park-View Resort , do not hesitate. Lodging in Fish Creek and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.

Not sure if these are the right properties for you, or just want to explore more hotels? Search here for more Fish Creek hotels:

More About Fish Creek

Fish Creek is on the west shore of the Door Peninsula, along the Bay of Green Bay. The harbor is protected from the rest of the bay, so the waters are calm here, making it a great place to swim, kayak, or stand-up paddleboard. The Green Bay shore of Door County has amazing sunsets.

Things to Do in Fish Creek

If you’re looking for other things to do, our post on the best things to do in Fish Creek WI is a great starting point.

Places to Eat in Fish Creek

Fish Creek has lots of great restaurants, many of which are walkable from downtown. Our post on the best restaurants in Fish Creek, WI can help guide you to the best option to feed the hungry travelers in your group. Many of the restaurants offering fish boils can be found in Fish Creek.

What To Consider When Choosing a Door County Hotel

Give some careful thought when choosing a Door County hotel on the water. Questions you should consider include:

  • Is this hotel kid-friendly?
  • Is this hotel pet-friendly?
  • Which village or city do I want to stay in?
  • Which body of water is this on?
  • Do I want a private beach area?

Is this hotel kid and pet friendly?

Some travel to bond with the family, including kids, grandkids, and even fido. Others are looking to get away from the kids and want a break from the noise and business that kids and pets bring along. Not all Door County hotels are kid and pet friendly. Some properties even have no-children policies! Make sure to research the property carefully.

Which village or city do I want to stay in?

Door County’s villages and cities each offer something unique to travelers. Some are located along Green Bay, others on Lake Michigan. Some have amenities like grocery stores, others do not. Some are great for shopping, while others are great for getting away from crowds.

Which Body of Water?

The most important matter to decide when picking a Door County hotel on the water is: “Which body of water do you want to stay on?”.

Hotels on Lake Michigan will offer cool breezes, gorgeous sunrises, and freedom from crowds. Locals call this the “quiet side” of Door County. If you are a morning coffee kind of person, you might like a hotel on Lake Michigan. On the other hand, most will not want to swim in these waters until later in the season when air and water temperatures rise.

Hotels on Green Bay offer beautiful sunsets and closer access to restaurants and other amenities. In addition, the water warms up quicker here, so you might be more likely to swim in Green Bay. If you are an evening cocktail sort of person rather than a morning coffee sort of person, you might like a hotel on the water of Green bay. On the other hand, this is the busy side of Door County. You might encounter crowds here – great for those who like to see and be seen, but less than ideal for those who want more solitude.

Sturgeon Bay is a smaller bay off of Green Bay. Hotels on Sturgeon Bay will offer access to the amenities of the City of Sturgeon Bay, Door County’s only city.

Do I Want a Private Beach Area?

You might assume that a Door County hotel on the water has a beach area for swimming, but this is not necessarily the case. Some hotels do not offer a private beach area, even if they have private shoreline. However, even if the hotel you choose does not have a private beach, Door County has many public beaches.

FAQ

Which Fish Creek Hotels allow pets?

Julie’s Park Café & Motel, Peninsula Park-View Resort

Which Fish Creek Hotels have pools?

Homestead Suites, Park-View Resort

Which Fish Creek Hotels are family friendly?

Homestead Suites, Julie’s Park, Peninsula Park-View Resort, Main Street Motel, Harbor Guest House

About the author
Mark Stoneman
Hi! My name is Mark! I have been a resident of Door County for almost ten years now, and I'm glad to help you say "Hello" to Door County. I believe that travel helps to change lives, and because of that, I want to help you improve your life through travel.