5 Best Restaurants In Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Fish Creek is where the tourism industry in Door County began. These Fish Creek restaurants have kept up the tradition of showing outstanding hospitality to those looking for rest and relaxation amidst the beauty of Door County.

white clapboard building in Fish Creek, Wisconsin with the words "Fish Creek, Wisconsin Restaurants hellodoorcounty.com"
Adapted from “The White Gull Inn” by Richie Disterheft via Flickr. Used by permission (CC BY-SA 2.0).


In this post, we will cover the 5 best restaurants in Fish Creek, including

Be sure to scroll to the end of the article for more information about Fish Creek, including suggested article to help you decide what to do and where to stay.

5 Best Restaurants in Fish Creek, WI

The Best Fish Creek Supper Club: Alexander’s of Door County

A contemporary take on the supper club experience, Alexander’s of Door County is one of the most highly rated restaurants on the Peninsula. The decor is more clean and modern than most supper clubs, and the menu quite a bit more adventurous. However, the central element of a supper club endures at Alexander’s. This is a place to linger.

Phone: +19208683532
Address: 3667 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212

The Best Pizza Restaurant in Fish Creek: Wild Tomato

With a location near Peninsula State Park in Fish Creek, Wild Tomato is a perfect place to recharge after hiking, snowshoeing, or cross-country skiing. Wild Tomato offers wood-fired pizza, salads, sandwiches, and burgers. Wild Tomato also has a location in Sister Bay.

Phone: 920-868-3095
Address: 4023 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212

The Best Seafood Restaurant in Fish Creek: Skaliwag’s

Skaliwag’s is a newcomer to Fish Creek but is just the most recent iteration of a successful restaurant originating in Algoma.

Look, we know that a pirate-themed restaurant may not seem all that legit. But, hear us out. This restaurant has built up an enormous reputation in Northeastern Wisconsin, with loyal customers including players for the Green Bay Packers.

Things you can’t expect at Skaliwag’s: The same menu every time you visit. A quick in-and-out dining experience. Cheap eats.

Things you can expect at Skaliwag’s: The freshest seafood possible. (Steaks, too.) Personal attention from the chef/owner. Surprising menu choices. Delectable flavors that you won’t find anywhere else.

Give it a try. But, word to the wise: Come with lots of time and lots of money.

Address: 4135 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212
Phone: 920-868-3634

The Best Breakfast Restaurant in Fish Creek: White Gull Inn Restaurant

white clapboard building. Sign that says "White Gull Inn."
Via Hello Door County.

White Gull Inn is located in Fish Creek’s historic Founders Square. Classic, white clapboard buildings, old trees, and nearby parkside access to the bay make this a picturesque place to take a meal. Located in a lovely old bed and breakfast, you’ll get a great feel for Door County’s timeless charm.

White Gull Inn’s brunch is a Door County classic. A crowd-pleaser is their cherry-stuffed French toast.

A regular fish boil schedule rounds out the offerings of this must-visit Door County establishment.

Address: 4225 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212
Phone: 920-868-3517

The Best Comfort Food Restaurant in Fish Creek: Julie’s Park Cafe & Motel

white building. Julie's Park Café & Motel, Fish Creek, Door County, WI
Via Hello Door County.

Julie’s Park Cafe is Fish Creek’s favorite restaurant for American homestyle comfort food. Serving breakfast and lunch, Julie’s Park Cafe claims that “you won’t need dinner” if you eat with them.

Located right at the entrance of Peninsula State Park (hence the name), this is a great place to catch lunch after a brisk morning hike. Or, if you’ve gone through a long, cold, wet night in a tent at a park campground, this is a place to dry out and warm up over a piping hot cup of coffee.

Address: 4020 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212
Phone: 920-868-2999

More Information about Fish Creek

Places to Stay in Fish Creek

Finding lodging in Door County can be difficult due to high demand and the local nature of the properties. Most hotels are not part of a chain in Door County, so it can be hard to know what you will get. Our article on the best hotels in Fish Creek, WI can help you decide where to make your home base.

Things To Do in Fish Creek

If you are looking for things to do to work up an appetite or burn off those calories you consumed at a Fish Creek restaurant, check out our article on the best things to do in Fish Creek, WI.