15 Best Restaurants In Fish Creek

Here are the best restaurants in Fish Creek, WI:

Discover the culinary gems of Fish Creek, Wisconsin, through our detailed guide. We’ll introduce you to the top fifteen restaurants that define the local dining scene, each offering unique flavors and experiences. Whether it’s fish boils, cherry-stuffed French toast, pub fare, or pizza, Fish Creek has something to suit every taste.

Are you looking to make Fish Creek your base for exploring Door County? Check out our article on the best hotels in Fish Creek.

white clapboard building in Fish Creek, Wisconsin with the words "Fish Creek, Wisconsin Restaurants hellodoorcounty.com"
Adapted from “The White Gull Inn” by Richie Disterheft via Flickr. Used by permission (CC BY-SA 2.0).

Best Restaurants in Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Wild Tomato

wild tomato storefront sign

After a long hike in Peninsula State Park, there’s nothing like grabbing a pizza from Wild Tomato. It’s my go-to spot for a delicious, wood-fired pizza with a local twist. Perfectly situated near the park’s entrance, it’s the best place to refuel and relax.

Menu

Wild Tomato offers a mouth-watering selection of wood-fired pizzas, each with its unique flavor. Whether you crave the earthy notes of goat cheese and sun-dried tomatoes or the classic zest of sausage and pepperoni, their menu is a playground for your taste buds.

Ambiance

The vibe at Wild Tomato is welcoming and warm, much like the comforting glow of their wood-fired oven. It’s a spot where families and friends gather, sharing laughter and stories over slices of the best pizza in town.

Quick Facts

Pelletier’s Restaurant & Fish Boil

white clapboard buidling. Sign that says Pelletier's.
Via Hello Door County.

Tucked away in the old town section of Fish Creek, Pelletier’s Restaurant & Fish Boil is a must-visit spot. Known for having the most regular fish boil schedule, this restaurant offers an authentic Door County experience. The welcoming atmosphere and traditional fish boils make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Menu

Pelletier’s is renowned for its traditional nightly fish boils, and the menu doesn’t stop there. From early riser breakfast specials to an array of lunch options including soups, sandwiches, and salads, there’s something for everyone. Don’t forget to try their cherry stuffed french toast or the Door County cherry pie – they’re local favorites!

Ambiance

This cozy spot offers a warm, inviting ambiance perfect for family dinners or a casual meal with friends. With patio dining available, you can enjoy your meal while soaking in the charming surroundings of Fish Creek’s old town.

Quick Facts

Barringer’s

table setting at a restaurant in Door County
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

If you’re craving a genuine supper club experience in Fish Creek, Barringer’s is your go-to spot. Owned by JR Schoenfeld, the mastermind behind Chives Door County and a fleet of local food trucks, Barringer’s is where the warmth of a Wisconsin supper club meets the elegance of a steakhouse. It’s a place where every bite feels like home, yet every dish is a work of art.

Menu

Barringer’s menu is a symphony of flavors. It offers an array of fresh seafood and succulent steak options. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic surf ‘n’ turf or something more adventurous, the menu caters to all tastes with its fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Barringer’s marries modern sophistication with cozy, supper club charm. The dining space is inviting, with a contemporary flair that doesn’t overshadow the warmth and friendliness you’d expect from a local favorite.

Quick Facts

Hill Street

Group Of Friends Enjoying Evening Meal In Restaurant
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

As a local, I can’t get enough of Hill Street. It’s the go-to spot in Fish Creek for a relaxed yet vibrant dining experience. Whether you’re looking for a cozy corner or a lively bar scene, this place has it all. The food is a delightful mix of comfort classics and innovative dishes that keep you coming back for more.

Menu

Hill Street’s menu is a treasure trove of flavors. Favorites include the meatball parmigiana sandwich and the unforgettable fried chicken sandwich. And let’s not forget about the house fries – simply irresistible!

Ambiance

Expect a blend of coziness and excitement here. Hill Street is a sometimes cozy, sometimes raucous bar right in the heart of downtown. The dual personality of this spot means you’re in for a good time, no matter what mood you’re in.

Quick Facts

Hill Street is more than just a restaurant; it’s a vital part of our Fish Creek community. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, make sure to stop by and experience this gem for yourself!

Kettle Black Fish Boil

white clapboard building. Sign that says "Kettle Black Fish Boil"
Via Hello Door County.

At Kettle Black Fish Boil, you’re in for a unique treat. This local favorite takes the traditional Door County fish boil to a new level with a flavorful twist: a Cajun fish boil. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that tantalizes your taste buds and captures the essence of local and Cajun culinary traditions.

Menu

The highlight here is, undoubtedly, the Cajun fish boil. A mouth-watering mix of seafood and spices, it brings a bit of the South to the North. Alongside this star dish, expect classic sides that complement the main course perfectly.

Ambiance

Kettle Black offers an inviting, casual atmosphere where the aroma of spices and the warmth of the community fill the air. It’s a place where both locals and visitors gather for not just a meal, but a memorable dining experience.

Quick Facts

BaySide Tavern

Interior of Bayside Tavern in Fish Creek, WI

BaySide Tavern offers more than just a meal; it’s a dive into Fish Creek’s rich history and culture. Picture a classic, wood-paneled bar where every corner has a story to tell. It’s not just about eating; it’s about experiencing the essence of Door County with every bite.

Menu

BaySide Tavern’s menu is a delightful mix of comfort and creativity. From the chili dogs and potato salads to the tastiest cherry pie around, each dish is a nod to local flavors. Don’t miss out on their draft beer selection, offering the best of local and craft options.

Ambiance

The ambiance at BaySide Tavern is like stepping into a warm, welcoming home. The wood paneling and cozy seating invite you to relax and soak in the local vibe. It’s the perfect spot to unwind after a day exploring Fish Creek, where every visit feels like coming home.

Quick Facts

Julie’s Park Cafe

white building. Julie's Park Café & Motel, Fish Creek, Door County, WI
Via Hello Door County.

Right at the entrance to Peninsula State Park, you’ll find Julie’s Park Cafe. It’s a cozy spot known for its hearty breakfasts and lunches. The cafe prides itself on being a local favorite in Fish Creek, serving up traditional American fare in a casual setting.

Menu

Julie’s Park Cafe offers a variety of mouth-watering dishes. For breakfast, think fluffy pancakes, omelets loaded with fresh ingredients, and unique offerings like Cherry Crepes. Lunchtime brings equally tempting options, from classic sandwiches to fresh salads. The cafe also caters to vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free diets.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Julie’s Park Cafe is inviting and friendly. It’s the kind of place where locals and tourists alike feel right at home. With its charming decor and comfortable seating, it’s perfect for a leisurely meal. Plus, the outdoor seating offers a delightful way to enjoy a sunny day in Fish Creek.

Quick Facts

The English Inn

sign for The English Inn

Discover the charm of The English Inn, a favorite among the best restaurants in Fish Creek. This cozy spot brings a touch of England to Door County, offering a unique blend of traditional and local flavors. It’s the perfect place for a relaxed dinner, a special celebration, or a cozy evening with friends.

Menu

The English Inn’s menu is a culinary journey. Start with their traditional Baked French Onion Soup or the Original Goat Cheese Salad. Seafood lovers will adore the Door County Whitefish, fresh from local waters. For a hearty meal, the Prime Rib or Rib-eye Steak is a must-try. And don’t miss the extensive wine list, featuring exquisite choices like the Cabernet Sauvignon from Chateau Ste. Michelle.

Ambiance

Step into The English Inn and feel the warmth of traditional English hospitality. The interior is cozy and inviting, with a classic charm that makes every visit special. Whether you’re dining by the crackling fireplace or enjoying the scenic view from the patio, the ambiance here is all about comfort and elegance.

Quick Facts

The Whistling Swan Inn

Elegant Dinner Setting Abstract Macro Background
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

The Whistling Swan Inn, standing as the oldest operating inn in the Door Peninsula, offers more than just a place to stay. Its history spans over a century, with a journey across the ice of Green Bay marking its incredible relocation. Known for its exquisite cuisine and intimate atmosphere, the Whistling Swan Inn is a cornerstone of Fish Creek’s dining scene, inviting guests to savor every moment.

Menu

The Whistling Swan Inn boasts an inventive, ever-evolving menu that captivates the taste buds of every guest. With a carefully curated wine and beer list, the dining experience here is nothing short of exceptional. Though the specifics of the menu weren’t found, the reputation suggests a culinary journey that promises to delight.

Ambiance

The inn’s rich history contributes to its unique ambiance, blending elegance with coziness. The intimate dining room seats 56 guests, making each meal a personal and memorable experience. The inn’s storied past and attentive service create an atmosphere that’s perfect for both relaxation and culinary exploration.

Quick Facts

Alexander’s

sign for Alexander's restaurant

As a local, I can’t get enough of Alexander’s. This gem in Fish Creek is where elegance meets comfort. Their menu is a parade of delights, showcasing the best of American and seafood dishes. Whether it’s a quiet dinner or a gathering with friends, Alexander’s sets the bar high.

Menu

At Alexander’s, every bite is a celebration. The stuffed pork chop and Chicken Alexander are local legends. Seafood lovers, brace yourselves for the Shrimp Carbonara and BBQ Salmon. And oh, the desserts! The in-house Chocolate Peanut Butter Torte is a slice of heaven.

Ambiance

Think cozy, think classy – that’s Alexander’s. It’s a warm embrace of sophistication and comfort. Whether it’s the chatter at the bar or the clinking of fine dining in the background, the ambiance here is just perfect for making memories.

Quick Facts

Alexander’s is not just a restaurant; it’s a tradition, a celebration of fine taste and warm gatherings. It’s where every local feels proud to bring their guests, and every visitor wishes they were a local. It’s the heart of Fish Creek’s culinary scene, and a must-visit for anyone who believes that every meal should be a memorable one.

Loft

chef holding plate of food at a restaurant in Door County
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Loft, a gem among the best restaurants in Fish Creek, WI, offers a unique blend of American and International cuisine. As a local, I appreciate the creative flavors and the inviting atmosphere this place has to offer. It’s a spot where good food and good times go hand in hand.

Menu

The menu at Loft is a testament to culinary diversity, featuring items ranging from tasty tuna and chicken pies to grilled prawns. The chefs here are committed to quality, ensuring that every dish, whether it’s a local favorite or an international classic, is nothing short of spectacular.

Ambiance

Loft is housed in one of the most noticeable buildings in Northern Door County. The ambiance here strikes a harmonious balance between elegant and casual. It’s the kind of place where each meal feels special, whether you’re here for a leisurely lunch, a delightful dinner, or just to grab a drink with friends.

Quick Facts

GUSTO

table setting at a Door County restaurant
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

GUSTO is a celebrated spot in Fish Creek, WI, known for its vibrant flavors and friendly atmosphere. As a local, I find myself drawn to its charming setting and the mouth-watering dishes that promise a memorable dining experience every time.

Menu

GUSTO’s menu is a testament to culinary innovation, offering a delightful array of dishes. It’s the place to go for a fusion of taste that satisfies the soul. From the first bite to the last, GUSTO’s cuisine speaks the language of flavor with a distinct, creative voice.

Ambiance

Set in a cozy spot at 4192 Main Street, GUSTO provides a warm and inviting ambiance. It’s a place where laughter blends with the clinking of glasses, and every meal feels like a celebration. The welcoming vibe makes it a favorite for both locals and visitors alike.

Quick Facts

Welcker’s Lounge

Close up on a glass of beer and people drinking in a bar or pub
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Welcker’s Lounge is not just a restaurant; it’s a journey back to the roaring 1920s. As a Fish Creek local, I’m constantly drawn to its speakeasy charm and delectable bites. It’s the perfect spot to unwind and indulge in some of the best culinary delights that Fish Creek has to offer.

Menu

The menu at Welcker’s Lounge is a delightful mix of classic American cuisine with a creative twist. Known for its charming atmosphere, the lounge offers an array of mouth-watering libations and dishes that are sure to razzle-dazzle your taste buds. From creative cocktails to scenic views, every visit feels like a special occasion.

Ambiance

Stepping into Welcker’s Lounge is like taking a step back in time. The speakeasy theme is executed with impeccable attention to detail, offering a cozy yet sophisticated setting. Whether you’re here for a casual drink or a full meal, the warm and inviting atmosphere makes every visit memorable.

Quick Facts

Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard

exterior of not licked yet frozen custard

A must-visit spot in Fish Creek, WI, Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard stands out as one of the best for its famous custard and delightful food. As a local, I’ve cherished the moments here, enjoying the world-class custard under the beautiful Door County sky.

Menu

Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard is renowned for its delicious real frozen custard and desserts. But that’s not all; they also serve yummy burgers and sandwiches, using the finest Door County ingredients. It’s a perfect blend of sweet and savory that never fails to impress.

Ambiance

Nestled before the entrance to Peninsula State Park, this spot offers more than just great food. It’s a place where Door County’s wildlife and landscape come together, creating a unique and unforgettable experience. The outdoor seating is perfect for enjoying your treats while embracing the scenic views.

Quick Facts

Bayside Coffee

coffee beans
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Bayside Coffee is a cozy spot in Fish Creek, WI, offering a refreshing blend of coffee, snacks, and delightful bites. As a local, I find myself drawn to its relaxing patio area, perfect for a leisurely coffee break or a casual meet-up with friends.

Menu

Bayside Coffee’s menu is a blend of comfort and creativity, featuring delicious treats like the turkey cranberry bleu sandwich and the PB and J. Their iced chai tea latte is a personal favorite, perfect for sipping while enjoying the scenic view.

Ambiance

The charm of Bayside Coffee lies in its inviting outdoor seating area, offering a tranquil spot to unwind. The view of the boats and the gentle buzz of the town make it an ideal backdrop for enjoying their top-rated coffee and snacks.

Quick Facts

Tips for Dining in Fish Creek

Image showing an outdoor dining scene in front of water and a sunset. Text says: Fish Creek Restaurants.

Exploring the best restaurants in Fish Creek is a delightful experience. To make the most of your culinary adventures, consider these handy tips:

  • Verify Hours: Door County is full of surprises, and sometimes restaurant hours are too! Always call ahead to confirm the current hours, as they can vary from what’s published.
  • Make Reservations: Especially during peak tourist season, Fish Creek’s popular spots fill up fast. Secure your table by making a reservation ahead of time.
  • Explore Local Flavors: Don’t miss out on the unique local dishes. Fish Creek restaurants offer an array of specialties that reflect the rich culinary heritage of the area.
  • Mind the Dress Code: Some places might have a dress code, particularly the fancier ones. A quick check before you go can save you from potential embarrassment.
  • Parking Considerations: Especially in the busy season, parking can be tricky. Allow extra time to find a spot or consider options like walking or biking if you’re staying nearby.
  • Support Local Businesses: Whenever possible, choose locally-owned and operated restaurants. It’s a great way to support the community and enjoy authentic local experiences.

Pet-Friendly Restaurants Near Fish Creek

family dining with a dog in Door County

Fish Creek is a paradise for pet lovers, offering a variety of restaurants where your furry friends are more than welcome. These pet-friendly spots understand that meals are better with your best pal by your side. Remember to call ahead to ensure the outdoor seating is available for you and your pet. Here’s a list of pet-friendly restaurants near Fish Creek:

  • Blue Horse Cafe
  • LOFT
  • Bayside Coffee
  • White Gull Inn
  • Pelletier’s Restaurant & Fish Boil
  • Barringer’s Restaurant
  • The English Inn
  • Sweetie Pies
  • Julie’s Park Cafe & Motel
  • Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Fish Creek
  • Door County Kravings Coffee House
  • Pelletier’s Restaurant
  • Summertime

Family-Friendly Restaurants Near Fish Creek

Image showing an outdoor dining scene in front of water and a sunset. Text says: Fish Creek Restaurants.

Fish Creek is not just known for its stunning views but also for its family-friendly dining scene. Whether you’re craving a cozy cafe or a hearty meal, there’s a spot for every family. Remember, it’s always a good idea to call ahead to make sure the restaurant can accommodate your family’s needs. Here are some top picks for family-friendly restaurants near Fish Creek:

  • Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille
  • The English Inn
  • Pelletier’s Restaurant & Fish Boil
  • White Gull Inn
  • Blue Horse Beach Cafe
  • Julie’s Park Cafe & Motel

These places not only offer delicious food but also a welcoming atmosphere for families with kids.

Fish Creek Restaurants with Outdoor Seating

Fish Creek is not just a feast for the eyes with its stunning landscapes, but it’s also a paradise for food lovers. Outdoor seating in restaurants here offers not just delicious food but also breathtaking views that can elevate your dining experience. Whether you’re craving a casual coffee or a sumptuous supper, these restaurants have got you covered. But remember, it’s always wise to call ahead to verify that the restaurant has outdoor seating available, especially during peak seasons or special events. Here are some great spots near Fish Creek where you can enjoy your meal under the open sky:

  • Old Post Office Restaurant
  • Door County Creamery
  • Macready Artisan Bread Company
  • Waterfront Restaurant
  • Julie’s Park Cafe
  • White Gull Inn
  • Blue Horse Cafe
  • Wild Tomato Wood Fired Pizza and Grille
  • Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard
  • Chef’s Hat Cafe
  • Chop
  • Wilson’s Restaurant
  • Wild Tomato Sister Bay
  • Harbor Fish Market & Grille
  • Alexander’s Restaurant
  • Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard
  • Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille
  • Pelletier’s Restaurant and Fish Boil
  • Bayside Tavern
  • Loft

Enjoy the fresh air and the great food these restaurants offer!

Fish Creek Restaurants with Water Views

Fish Creek boasts several restaurants where you can enjoy not just a meal but also a stunning view of the water. As a local, these spots are my go-to for a scenic dining experience. Remember, it’s always best to call ahead to verify that the restaurant you choose has the water view you’re looking for. Here are some of the top picks near Fish Creek:

  • Waterfront Restaurant
  • Old Post Office Restaurant
  • Harbor Fish Market & Grille
  • Chef’s Hat Cafe
  • Wilson’s Restaurant
  • Chives Door County
  • Boathouse on the Bay
  • Coyote Roadhouse
  • Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant & Butik
  • Carrington
  • Top Deck Restaurant and Bar

Enjoy the view and the flavors at these fantastic Fish Creek dining spots!

More Door County Restaurant Roundups

If you’re looking for a restaurant in Door County, we have lots of other content to help you find the perfect eatery for you. Check out our other restaurant roundup reviews:

More About Fish Creek

Fish Creek has great restaurants, but it has much more to offer as well.

Given its proximity to Peninsula State Park and all the businesses that line its street, I think that it is the best all-around place to stay in Door County. If you are thinking about making Fish Creek your home base for a Door County vacation, make sure to check out our article on the best hotels in Fish Creek.

Fish Creek also has lots of great shops, attractions, and things to do. Check out our article on the best things to do in Fish Creek to find the perfect activity for you.

Fish Creek Farewell: A Taste to Remember

As our culinary voyage through Fish Creek concludes, we leave with satisfied palates and cherished memories. These top restaurants don’t just serve meals; they offer experiences wrapped in the warmth of local hospitality and the rich tapestry of Wisconsin’s flavors. Whether you’re a resident or a traveler, Fish Creek’s dining scene is a melodious symphony of taste, tradition, and innovation, promising each visitor a deliciously memorable farewell.

About the author
Mark Stoneman
Hi! My name is Mark! I have been a resident of Door County for almost ten years now, and I'm glad to help you say "Hello" to Door County. I believe that travel helps to change lives, and because of that, I want to help you improve your life through travel.