Many travelers consider Sister Bay in Door County, Wisconsin to be one of the most memorable places they have ever visited. Unfortunately, finding accommodations in Sister Bay can be difficult. Since the hotels in Sister Bay are mostly privately owned, not chain hotels, you aren’t quite sure what the property is like. As Door County locals, we at HelloDoorCounty.com can help you decide which hotel is best for you. Here is a list of the 7 best hotels in Sister Bay, Wisconsin.
This page contains affiliate links. This means that if you click on the link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This helps us provide content to help you plan life-changing travel experiences. Thanks!
Summary
This post will start off with a comparison table that will help you get a quick overview of the best hotels in Sister Bay. This might give you exactly what you need, but if you want to go deeper, we’ll talk in-depth about each of the best hotels, including:
- All-around best hotel in Sister Bay
- Best upscale hotel in Sister Bay
- Best Sister Bay hotel to get away from the crowds
- Best Sister Bay Hotel for couples
- Best hotel in Sister Bay for local flavor
- Best pet-friendly hotel in Sister Bay
- Best walkable hotel in Sister Bay
In addition, make sure to scroll to the end of the article for more great information, including:
- Sister Bay hotel search form
- More information about Sister Bay, WI
- What to consider when booking a hotel in Door County, WI
- Frequently Asked Questions
If you find a hotel that you like, do not hesitate to book it. Rooms in Door County fully book up in the prime tourist season, and many travelers book their accommodations a year in advance. Many properties offer free cancellations, so your risk is minimal in making a booking.
Sister Bay, WI Hotel Comparison Table
7 Best Hotels in Sister Bay, WI
All-Around Best Hotel in Sister Bay, WI: Pheasant Park Resort
The all-around best hotel in Sister Bay, WI is Pheasant Park Resort. We are rating Pheasant Park Resort the best hotel in Sister Bay due to its walkability, family-friendly amenities, cleanliness, and solid guest experiences.
Pheasant Park Resort is great for:
- Families
- Couples
- Walkability
Families will appreciate the indoor and outdoor pools, the playground, and separate bedrooms to let everyone spread out.
Couples will enjoy being in walking distance to the dining and shopping of Sister Bay. Once you park at Pheasant Park, there will be no need to fire up the car the rest of your visit.
Accomodations
Pheasant Park Resort has the following accommodation types:
- 2 bedroom suites with hot tubs. Sleeps 6.
- 3 bedroom suites. Sleeps 8.
Amenities
In-room amenities at Pheasant Park vary by room but can include:
- Free Wi-Fi
- Fireplace
- Balcony
- Dining area
- Living room
- Full kitchens
- Daily housekeeping
Facility amenities include:
- Outdoor pool
- Indoor pool
- Hot tub
- BBQ grills
- Gym
- Sauna
- Business Center
- Playground
- Picnic area
- Outdoor fireplace
- Garden
Location
Pheasant Park is located at 2236 Mill Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234. This is right in the heart of the Village of Sister bay and only blocks from Sister Bay’s waterfront downtown, full of boutique shops, restaurants, and other attractions. This is an extremely walkable location. You will probably want to get in your car to explore the rest of Door County, but you won’t need to get into your car to fill your day with lots of activities to occupy your whole group.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Sister Bay: 0.5 miles
- Ephraim Public Beach: 0.6 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 20.8 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 9.8 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 5.8 miles
Learn More
Pheasant Park Resort is the all-around best hotel in beautiful Sister Bay, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about the Pheasant Park Resort before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Pheasant Park Resort, do not hesitate. Lodging in Sister Bay and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Upscale Sister Bay Hotel: The Dörr Hotel
The best upscale hotel in Sister Bay is The Dörr Hotel. Door County’s newest hotel, The Dörr Hotel features a unique blend of rustic and modern decor and sits right on Sister Bay’s waterfront. This Sister Bay hotel is great for encountering Door County’s natural beauty while also enjoying chic digs.
Couples will especially enjoy the chic, modern decor, the romantic water views, and the walkability in Sister Bay’s downtown area.
The Dörr Hotel is great for:
- Couples
- Aesthetes
- Walkability
- Waterviews
Accomodations
The Dörr Hotel offers the following accommodation types:
- King suites. Sleep 4.
- King rooms. Sleep 2.
- Double queen rooms. Sleep 4.
Amenities
In-room amenities can vary by room at The Dörr Hotel, but can include:
- Private patio or balcony
- Sleeper sofa
- Sitting area
- Cable TV
- Bluetooth Sound Systerm
- Coffee maker
- Hair dryer
- Free Wi-Fi
Facility amenities include:
- Free breakfast
- Lobby bar
- Outdoor fireplace
Location
One of the main attraction of The Dörr Hotel is its location right in the heart of downtown Sister Bay. This property has water views and is easily walkable to Sister Bay’s shopping boutiques, restaurants, and cultural attractions. The Dörr Hotel is located at 2329 Mill Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Sister Bay: 0.1 miles
- Sister Bay Beach: 0.1 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 20.1 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 10.1 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 5.2 miles
Learn More
The Dörr Hotel is the best upscale hotel in beautiful Sister Bay, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about The Dörr Hotel before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for The Dörr Hotel, do not hesitate. Lodging in Sister Bay and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Sister Bay Hotel to Get Away from the Crowds: The Inn at Little Sister Hill
The Inn at Little Sister Hill is the best hotel in Sister Bay, WI to get away from the crowds. A little more tucked away than some of the other hotels in Sister Bay, this is the place to stay if you want to have a slightly more rustic and secluded feel.
The Inn at Little Sister Hill is great for:
- Families
- Nature lovers
Accomodations
The Inn at Little Sister Hill has the following accommodation types:
- 1 bedroom suites. Sleep 4.
- 2 bedroom suites. Sleep 6
Guests should be aware that the second bedroom in the two bedroom suites is an upstairs loft.
Amenities
All suites at the Inn at Little Sister Hill have the following in-room amenities:
- Separate bedrooms
- Living room
- Separate dining space
- Full kitchen
- Free Wi-Fi
Facility amenities include:
- Outdoor pool
- BBQ grill
- Playground
- Outdoor fire pit
Location
The Inn at Little Sister Hill is located at 2715 Little Sister Hill Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234. This is about 1 miles west of downtown Sister Bay.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Sister Bay: 1.0 miles
- Sister Bay Beach: 1.6 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 20.0 miles
- Cana Island Lighthouse: 11.0 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 3.7 miles
Learn More
The Inn at Little Sister Hill is the best hotel in beautiful Sister Bay, WI to get away from the crowds. Perhaps you need to learn more about The Inn at Little Sister Hill before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for The Inn at Little Sister Hill, do not hesitate. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Sister Bay Hotel for Couples: Country House Resort
Country House Resort is a casually elegant hotel with water views of Sister Bay. This lovely atmosphere in combination with their adult-only policy is why we have chosen the Country House Resort as the Best Sister Bay Hotel for Couples.
Country House Resort is great for:
- Couples
- Pet lovers
- Water views
Accomodations
Country House Resort offers the following accommodation types:
- Single king rooms
- Double king rooms
- Single queen rooms
- Double queen rooms
Amenities
In-room amenities at Country House Resort include:
- Free Wi-Fi
- Pet-friendly rooms
- Water view rooms
- Rooms with balconies
Facility amenities include:
- Hot tub
- Garden area with lounge furniture
Location
Country House Resort is located at 2468 Sunnyside Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234. It is set on a 27 acre property that offers a quiet and peaceful setting with water views that is not far from some of Door County’s best attractions.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Sister Bay: 1.0 miles
- Ephraim Public Beach: 0.9 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 20.0 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 11.0 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 4.9 miles
Learn More
Country House Resort is the best hotel for couples in Sister Bay, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about Country House Resort before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Country House Resort, do not hesitate. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Hotel for Local Flavor: Scandinavian Lodge
Much of what makes Door County culturally unique stems from the Scandinavian immigrants who settled the area. Settlers from Norway and Iceland brought along cuisine, architecture, and traditions that influence Door County to this day. Scandinavian Lodge helps you soak in that cultural heritage, which is why we are naming it Sister Bay’s best hotel for local flavor.
Scandinavian Lodge is a condominium style aparthotel. Families will especially appreciate the opportunity to spread out in the spacious accommodations that include separate bedrooms.
The onsite banquet hall also makes this a good location for events like family reunions and weddings.
However, travelers should be aware that daily housekeeping is not available.
Scandinavian Lodge is great for:
- Families
- Couples
- Events
Accommodations
- 1 bedroom condos. Sleep 4.
- 2 bedroom condos. Sleep 6.
- 3 bedroom condos. Sleep 8.
- Single king studio suites. Sleep 2.
Amenities
In-room amenities at a Scandinavian Lodge include:
- Balconies or patios
- Kitchens
- Separate dining areas
- Living room
- Fireplace
- Whirlpool tub
- Free Wi-Fi
- Cable TV
Property amenities include:
- Indoor pool
- Outdoor pool
- Sauna
- Playground
- Grills
- Gym
Location
Scandinavian Lodge is located at 10506 WI-57, Sister Bay, WI 54234. This is on the south side of Sister Bay. Sister Bay’s downtown attractions are walkable from Scandinavian Lodge. However, it is far enough from the downtown that most individuals will want to drive in.
Nearby Attractions
- Downtown Sister Bay: 0.5 miles
- Ephraim Public Beach: 0.7 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 19.8 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 10.4 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 5.0 miles
Learn More
Scandinavian Lodge is the best hotel for local flavor in Sister Bay, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about Scandinavian Lodge before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for the Scandinavian Lodge, do not hesitate. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Pet-Friendly Hotel in Sister Bay, WI: Open Hearth Lodge
Open Hearth Lodge is the best pet-friendly hotel in Sister Bay, WI. However, you don’t need to be a pet lover to enjoy this great hotel. This property has glowing comments from families and couples with or without pets. Positive comments include the hospitality of the staff and the cleanliness. In addition, Open Hearth Lodge is one of the few hotels in Sister Bay that offers a free breakfast.
Open Hearth Lodge is great for:
- Pet lovers
- Families
- Couples
Accomodations
Open Hearth Lodge offers the following accommodation types:
- 2 queen bed rooms. Sleep 4.
- 1 king bed rooms. Sleep 2.
- 1 king bed and 1 sofa bed rooms. Sleep 4.
- One-bedroom apartments with 1 king bed and 1 sofa bed. Sleep 4.
- Two-bedroom apartments with 2 king beds and 1 sofa bed. Sleep 6.
- 2 queen beds and 1 sofa bed rooms. Sleep 5.
- Whirlpool tub rooms
- Suites
- Pet-friendly rooms
Amenities
In-room amenities vary according to the type of accommodation. Amenities can include:
- Free Wi-Fi
- Kitchen
- Microwave
- Refrigerator
- Pet-friendly rooms
- Cable TV
- Coffee maker
- Whirlpool tub
Facility amenities include:
- Free continental breakfast
- Indoor pool
- Hot tub
- Sauna
- BBQ grils
- Garden
- Outdoor fireplace
- Gym
- Playground
Location
Open Hearth Lodge is located at 2669 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234. This is a little west of Sister Bay’s downtown and central location on the Door Peninsula, not far from many attractions. Many customers comment that they appreciate the spacious grounds of Open Hearth Lodge’s location.
Nearby Attractions
Nearby attractions include
- Downtown Sister Bay: 1.2 miles
- Ephraim Public Beach: 1.4 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 19.7 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 10.7 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 4.0 miles
Learn More
Open Hearth Lodge is the best pet-friendly hotel in beautiful Sister Bay, WI. However, Open Hearth Lodge is great not just for pet-lovers but also for families and couples. Perhaps you need to learn more about Open Hearth Lodge before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Open Hearth Lodge, do not hesitate. Lodging in Sister Bay and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Best Walkable Hotel: Goose and Twigs
The Best Walkable Hotel in Sister Bay, WI is Goose & Twigs. Located right in the heart of historic Sister Bay, WI, you will be within an easy stroll of restaurants, boutiques, cultural centers, and the waterfront. This is a small, boutique hotel that specializes in green travel, and its walkability is part of that design.
Goose & Twigs is a smaller property with more limited amenities than other hotels in the Sister Bay area. However, given its location right in the heart of Sister Bay, not far from this village’s many shops and attractions, you will have plenty to do.
Goose & Twigs is great for:
- Walkability
- Couples
- Green Travel
Accommodations
Gose & Twigs offers the following accommodation types:
- 1 king bed rooms. Sleep 3.
- 1 king bed, 1 sofa bed rooms. Sleep 5.
- 2 queen bed rooms. Sleep 4.
Amenities
In-room amenities at the Hillside Waterfront Resort include:
- Free Wi-Fi
- Cable TV
- Coffee / Tea Maker
Facility amenities include:
- EV charging station
- Onsite coffee shop
- Daily Reception
Location
Goose & Twigs is located at 2322 Mill Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234.
The biggest advantage of Goose & Twigs is its great location. Right in the heart of historic sister Bay, WI, and by the waterfront, this is a place of gorgeous waterviews, stunning sunsets, convenient walkability, and classic, old-timey charm.
Nearby Attractions
Nearby attractions include
- Downtown Sister Bay: 0.1 miles
- Sister Bay Beach: 0.1 miles
- Cave Point County Park: 20.4 miles
- Cana Island Light House: 18.0 miles
- Peninsula State Park: 11.6 miles
Learn More
Goose & Twigs is the best hotel for walkability in lovely Sister Bay, WI. Perhaps you need to learn more about Goose & Twigs before booking.
Check Availability
But, if you are interested in checking availability for Goose & Twigs , do not hesitate. Lodging in Ephraim and all of Door County books up well in advance, especially during the prime tourist season. Now is the time to act before this property does not have availability.
Search for More Hotels
Want to broaden your search for a Sister Bay hotel? We have partnered with some of the best Sister Bay properties to bring you great prices for excellent properties. Use our search bar to find the perfect hotel for your stay in Sister Bay:
More Information About Sister Bay, WI
Sister Bay is on the west shore of the Door Peninsula, along the Bay of Green Bay. The harbor is protected from the rest of the bay, so the waters are calm here, making it a great place to swim, kayak, or stand-up paddleboard. The Green Bay shore of Door County has amazing sunsets.
Things to Do in Sister Bay
Sister Bay has lots of things to do to keep your party occupied. One popular option is the Sisiter Bay Beach. Check out our post on Door County beaches to learn more about the Sister Bay Beach and lots of other awesome beaches on the peninsula.
If you’re looking for other things to do, our post on the best things to do in Sister Bay, WI is a great starting point.
Places to Eat in Sister Bay
Sister Bay has lots of great restaurants, many of which are walkable from downtown. Our post on the best restaurants in Sister Bay, WI can help guide you to the best option to feed the hungry travelers in your group.
What To Consider When Choosing a Door County Hotel
Give some careful thought when choosing a Door County hotel on the water. Questions you should consider include:
- Is this hotel kid-friendly?
- Is this hotel pet-friendly?
- Which village or city do I want to stay in?
- Which body of water is this on?
- Do I want a private beach area?
- Does this hotel have daily housekeeping?
Is this hotel kid and pet friendly?
Some travel to bond with the family, including kids, grandkids, and even fido. Others are looking to get away from the kids and want a break from the noise and business that kids and pets bring along. Not all Door County hotels are kid and pet friendly. Some properties even have no-children policies! Make sure to research the property carefully.
Which village or city do I want to stay in?
Door County’s villages and cities each offer something unique to travelers. Some are located along Green Bay, others on Lake Michigan. Some have amenities like grocery stores, others do not. Some are great for shopping, while others are great for getting away from crowds.
Which Body of Water?
The most important matter to decide when picking a Door County hotel on the water is: “Which body of water do you want to stay on?”.
Hotels on Lake Michigan will offer cool breezes, gorgeous sunrises, and freedom from crowds. Locals call this the “quiet side” of Door County. If you are a morning coffee kind of person, you might like a hotel on Lake Michigan. On the other hand, most will not want to swim in these waters until later in the season when air and water temperatures rise.
Hotels on Green Bay offer beautiful sunsets and closer access to restaurants and other amenities. In addition, the water warms up quicker here, so you might be more likely to swim in Green Bay. If you are an evening cocktail sort of person rather than a morning coffee sort of person, you might like a hotel on the water of Green bay. On the other hand, this is the busy side of Door County. You might encounter crowds here – great for those who like to see and be seen, but less than ideal for those who want more solitude.
Sturgeon Bay is a smaller bay off of Green Bay. Hotels on Sturgeon Bay will offer access to the amenities of the City of Sturgeon bay, Door County’s only city.
Do I Want a Private Beach Area?
You might assume that a Door County hotel on the water has a beach area for swimming, but this is not necessarily the case. Some hotels do not offer a private beach area, even if they have private shoreline. However, even if the hotel you choose does not have a private beach, Door County has many public beaches.
Frequent Asked Questions
Country House Resort
Open Hearth Lodge
Pheasant Park Resort
Scandinavian Lodge
Open Hearth Lodge
The Inn at Little Sister Hill
The Dörr Hotel
Open Hearth Lodge
