21 Best Restaurants in Sturgeon Bay

By Mark Stoneman
Door County Dining

Here are the best restaurants in Sturgeon Bay, WI:

Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, a captivating blend of industrial might and tourist charm in Door County, boasts a diverse culinary scene that caters to both hardworking locals and city escapees. In this article, we explore the gastronomic treasures that make dining in Sturgeon Bay an unforgettable experience.

Are you considering making Sturgeon Bay your homebase for a Door County vacation? Make sure to check out our roundup of Sturgeon Bay’s best hotels to find the right lodging for your party.

Find great deals on sturgeon bay hotels
the steel bridge in Sturgeon Bay, Door County, Wisconsin with the words "Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin Restaurants HelloDoorCounty.com"

Best Sturgeon Bay Restaurants

Kitty O’Reilly’s Irish Pub

Grid with scenes from Kitty O'Reilly's Irish Pub in Sturgeon Bay.

As a Sturgeon Bay local, Kitty O’Reilly’s Irish Pub holds a special place in my heart. It’s not just another restaurant; it’s where the heart of the town beats. With a vibe reminiscent of the beloved TV show “Cheers,” this spot welcomes everyone warmly.

You might rub elbows with a hardworking shipyard worker or share a toast with a C-suite exec from Chicago. And when the weather’s right, their beer garden offers one of the best outdoor dining experiences in Door County. The service? Impeccable. For a more detailed insight, don’t miss our full review.

Menu

From authentic Irish flavors to American classics, the menu at Kitty O’Reilly’s is a journey of taste. Whether you crave a hearty burger or the famed Cod Fish Fry, your taste buds are in for a treat. And if you’re in for a special morning, their breakfast lineup, including delights like Irish Eggs Benedict, will start your day just right.

Ambiance

Imagine a place where laughter fills the air, where the clink of glasses is a melody, and where every corner tells a story. That’s the ambiance at Kitty O’Reilly’s. It’s cozy yet buzzing with energy. The outdoor patio, with its inviting setup, becomes a haven during the warmer months.

Quick Facts

Nightingale Supper Club

Grid with images inside out and outside of Nightingale Supper Club. Superimposed text says: "Nightingale Supper Club."

Stepping into Nightingale Supper Club is like entering a cherished chapter of Sturgeon Bay’s history. A local gem since 1913, this place is more than a restaurant; it’s a community cornerstone where generations have celebrated life’s milestones. Beloved by locals and welcoming to visitors, Nightingale offers a classic Wisconsin supper club experience that’s both timeless and inviting.

The Friday night fish fries and Saturday night prime ribs are dishes you simply can’t miss. The ambiance encourages you to arrive early, grab a seat at the bar, and immerse yourself in the friendly, intergenerational vibe that makes Nightingale an enduring treasure. For a deeper dive into our experience, check our detailed review.

Menu

Nightingale’s menu is a parade of classic delights, featuring prime rib, fish fry, and an array of other entrees that honor the rich culinary tradition of Wisconsin. Every dish tells a story of quality and care, perfect for those seeking to savor the local flavor.

Ambiance

At Nightingale Supper Club, you’ll find a cozy, welcoming space where the clink of glasses and the murmur of conversations blend into a warm, inviting atmosphere. It’s a place where each visit feels like coming home, whether you’re a long-time local or a first-time visitor.

Quick Facts

Bluefront Cafe

Grey building. Bluefront Cafe in Sturgeon Bay, WI
Via Hello Door County.

If you’re looking for a lunch spot in Sturgeon Bay that breaks the mold, Bluefront Cafe is your go-to. Celebrated for its inventive and diverse menu, it stands out as a culinary hotspot.

From the deliciously unique fish tacos and banh mi to the comforting Bluefront Burger, the menu is a testament to the cafe’s commitment to freshness and quality. It’s a place where health-conscious eats meet hearty comfort food, making it one of the top lunch destinations in the area.

Menu

At Bluefront Cafe, the menu is a canvas of bold flavors and healthy choices. Options range from the health-conscious to indulgent comfort foods, ensuring there’s something to satisfy every palate. Signature dishes like the Meatloaf Sandwich, Fish Tacos, and a variety of wraps and salads highlight the cafe’s dedication to fresh, quality ingredients.

Ambiance

Bluefront Cafe offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a laid-back lunch. The bright, friendly space welcomes locals and tourists alike, setting the stage for a memorable meal. Whether you’re dropping in for a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely lunch, the cafe’s warm ambiance is part of its charm.

Quick Facts

Dedicated chef-owners keep the menu exciting with options like the popular fish tacos, banh mi, Asian wrap, and Susan’s tossed salad, ensuring a delightful dining experience at Bluefront Cafe.

Donny’s Glidden Lodge Restaurant

Superimposed text says: Donny's Glidden Lodge Restaurant. Background is the exterior of Donny's Glidden Lodge.

Donny’s Glidden Lodge Restaurant is a gem in Sturgeon Bay, offering not just meals but a full sensory experience. Plan ahead because this place fills up fast, and it’s definitely worth the wait.

For the best views of Lake Michigan, snag an early reservation. It’s like stepping into a different era with its timeless ambiance, making it an ideal spot for celebrating those special moments, especially anniversaries.

If you’d like to learn more about Donny’s Glidden Lodge, check out our full review of this classic Door County restaurant.

Menu

The menu is a showcase of Midwestern cuisine with a focus on quality and taste. Savor the Certified Black Angus cuts of meat and an array of sumptuous dishes that cater to every palate. From the Coldwater Lobster Tail to the Prime Rib, each dish promises a memorable dining experience.

Ambiance

Donny’s offers more than just a meal; it’s a journey back in time. The restaurant’s classic feel, combined with stunning views of Lake Michigan, creates an atmosphere where every visit feels like a special occasion. It’s a place where memories are made and cherished.

Quick Facts

Donny’s Glidden Lodge serves delicious Midwestern dishes in a setting that combines friendly service with a beautiful view of Lake Michigan. The restaurant is known for its Certified Black Angus cuts of meat and fresh ingredients, ensuring a top-notch dining experience.

Morning Glory by the Bay

traditional full american breakfast eggs pancakes with bacon and toast
Via Depositphotos.

Morning Glory by the Bay is a gem in Sturgeon Bay, a down-home spot beloved for its breakfast. It’s the kind of place that locals frequent and visitors remember. From the classic American diner breakfasts to the inviting atmosphere, it’s easy to see why it’s a favorite.

The restaurant’s second location on 3rd Avenue has quickly become a go-to spot for those seeking a warm, welcoming environment and high-quality food. Plus, the hash brown omelette is a must-try; it’s like a full breakfast served on one plate!

Menu

Morning Glory by the Bay offers a delightful breakfast and lunch menu that’s sure to please any palate. From the perfectly cooked eggs Benedict to the deliciously fresh and creative dishes, every meal is a hit. The Swedish pancakes and egg quesadillas come highly recommended, and for those who love a classic, the breakfast choices are plentiful and satisfying.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Morning Glory by the Bay is as inviting as its food. The charming building, with its open windows offering views of the harbor and lovely green spaces, creates a bright and airy feel. The staff’s friendly and attentive service adds to the family-friendly vibe, making it a place where both locals and visitors feel at home.

Quick Facts

Scaturo’s Baking Co & Cafe

bread food toast wood
Photo by Erika Ortiz on Pexels.com

Nestled in the heart of Sturgeon Bay, Scaturo’s Baking Co & Cafe is more than just a cafe; it’s a local legend. Owned by Rob and JoAnne Scaturo, this family-operated gem has been serving the community for over two decades.

It’s a place where the warmth of a family embrace meets the delight of homemade bakery and Jersey Style Pizza. Whether you’re craving a hearty breakfast, a homemade soup, or a slice of award-winning Cherry Pie, Scaturo’s is the place to be. And don’t get me started on their Jersey style pizza and traditional Wisconsin fish fry – it’s like a hug for your taste buds!

Menu

The menu at Scaturo’s is a testament to their commitment to freshness and quality. With ingredients sourced locally, every dish, from their breakfast specials to the Ultimate Door County Burger, is a burst of local flavor. The bakery section, filled with an assortment of bread, cookies, and pastries, ensures your sweet tooth is well catered for.

Ambiance

Scaturo’s ambiance is as inviting as its food. It’s a place that immediately feels like home, with a welcoming staff and a cozy setting that invites you to relax and enjoy. The testimonials of countless satisfied customers echo the cafe’s reputation for great service and an even greater dining experience.

Quick Facts

Sunrise Food & Drinks

breakfast food

Sunrise Food & Drinks is more than just a place to eat; it’s where flavors meet the sunrise in Sturgeon Bay. This cozy spot, known for its friendly vibes and scrumptious dishes, caters to those who cherish a hearty meal to kickstart their day or for a mid-day boost. They serve a delightful mix of American and Mexican cuisine, making it a must-visit for anyone looking for the best restaurants in Sturgeon Bay.

Menu

The menu is a celebration of comfort and taste. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic breakfast burrito or a dish with a Mexican twist, Sunrise Food & Drinks has you covered. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring that every bite takes you on a delicious journey. The breakfast burrito comes highly recommended and is a crowd favorite.

Ambiance

Walking into Sunrise Food & Drinks, you’re greeted with a casual and welcoming atmosphere. It’s a place where you can unwind, enjoy your meal, and feel the warmth of the community. The service is noted for its friendliness and efficiency, making your dining experience even more pleasant.

Quick Facts

Whether it’s for a fulfilling start to your day or a lunch that feels like a warm hug, Sunrise Food & Drinks promises a meal that’s not just eaten, but experienced. Remember, it’s not just about the food; it’s about the memories you create around the table.

Sonny’s Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria

pepperoni pizz
Via Pexels. Used by permission.

In the heart of Sturgeon Bay, Sonny’s Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria stands out as a culinary landmark. With over two decades of serving the community, Sonny’s is not just a restaurant; it’s an institution.

Known for its gourmet Chicago Style Pizza and authentic Verace Pizza Napoletana, the place offers a slice of Italy in Door County. The view here? Unbeatable. Gaze over the Michigan Street Steel Bridge, marina, and shipyard, all while savoring a meal that’s crafted with the finest, locally sourced ingredients.

Menu

Sonny’s menu is a celebration of Italian cuisine. Their signature pizzas, like the sausage and pepperoni-loaded Sonny’s special or the authentic Neapolitan “Regina margherita,” are just the beginning. Dive into their extensive selection, including pastas, salads, and a tempting array of entrees. Looking for something sweet? The dessert options will not disappoint.

Ambiance

When you step into Sonny’s, you’re stepping into a slice of Sturgeon Bay’s heart. The ambiance is warm, welcoming, and offers one of the best dining views in town. Overlooking the bay, each meal here is accompanied by a scenic backdrop, making your dining experience about more than just the food.

Quick Facts

Sonny’s boasts a broad menu featuring everything from pizzas to pastas, all made with fresh, local ingredients, and offers a picturesque view of the Bay, making it a beloved spot among locals and visitors alike.

Crate Restaurant

sushi
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Crate Restaurant in Sturgeon Bay is a culinary gem, a place where the finest sushi, seafood, and steak come together to create an unforgettable dining experience. With a menu that caters to a variety of tastes, Crate is a top pick for both locals and visitors.

The restaurant’s commitment to quality and its unique blend of Asian Fusion, Sushi, and Seafood make it a standout in the area. Known for its inviting atmosphere and excellent service, Crate is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable meal in Sturgeon Bay.

Menu

Crate’s menu is a testament to culinary diversity, offering everything from succulent sushi rolls to mouth-watering entrées. Favorites like calamari, pork belly ramen, and beef tenderloin showcase the kitchen’s skill and creativity. For sushi enthusiasts, the Nutty Asparagus roll is a delightful surprise, while the crab french onion soup adds a gourmet touch to a classic dish. Whether you’re in the mood for seafood or steak, Crate’s menu is sure to impress.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Crate is a harmonious blend of casual and trendy, making it the perfect spot for a relaxed dinner or a special night out. The atmosphere is often described as lively and welcoming, with a staff that’s dedicated to making your dining experience exceptional. Whether you’re there for a quick meal or a leisurely dinner, the ambiance at Crate adds a special touch to your dining experience.

Quick Facts

Dan’s Kitchen

Sweet and sour chicken and rice at an Asian restaurant in Door County
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Dan’s Kitchen is a gem in Sturgeon Bay, serving up authentic Southeast Asian dishes that have locals and visitors raving. With a menu brimming with flavorful options, from the classic Pad Thai to the comforting Pho, each dish is a testament to the rich culinary traditions of the region.

The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a casual lunch or a delightful dinner. Their commitment to quality and taste shines through in every bite, ensuring a memorable dining experience.

Menu

The menu at Dan’s Kitchen is a parade of flavors. Popular items like their savory Fried Rice, aromatic Pad See Ew, and the zesty Cashew dish stand out. Seafood lovers will rejoice over the Seafood Stir-Fry, and for those who crave something a bit spicy, the Tum Yum Kung is a must-try. It’s a menu that caters to a variety of tastes, each dish crafted with care and passion.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Dan’s Kitchen is all about warmth and comfort. It’s a place where the vibrant energy of Southeast Asia meets the cozy charm of Sturgeon Bay. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or settling in for a dinner with friends, the welcoming atmosphere makes every visit a pleasant experience.

Quick Facts

Brick Lot Pub & Grill

Close up on a glass of beer and people drinking in a bar or pub
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

One of my go-to spots in Sturgeon Bay, especially when I’m in the mood for a laid-back evening with friends. The Brick Lot Pub & Grill isn’t all about the menu – it’s the whole package: the vibe, the music, and the good company. It’s a place that blends the local charm with a fun, welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite for both drinks and casual dining.

Menu

While the Brick Lot Pub & Grill may be known more for its vibrant atmosphere, it doesn’t hold back on delivering tasty bites. The place boasts a selection of burgers, classic sandwiches, and broasted chicken. And let’s not forget the local favorite – their Friday Fish Fry, which has become a staple for both locals and visitors alike.

Ambiance

The Brick Lot Pub & Grill offers a unique open-dining concept. Imagine sipping on your favorite drink while enjoying a front seat view of downtown Sturgeon Bay, thanks to their front garage door that opens up the space. It’s the perfect spot to unwind after exploring the area, blending the comfort of indoor dining with the freshness of the outdoors.

Quick Facts

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Brick Lot Pub & Grill welcomes everyone with open arms and promises a relaxed, enjoyable experience with every visit.

5th and Jefferson Coffee House

close up photography of cup of coffee
Photo by Jason Villanueva on Pexels.com

5th and Jefferson Coffee House isn’t just your typical coffee spot in Sturgeon Bay; it’s a blend of delightful tastes and a slightly Bohemian vibe that sets it apart. Recognized for its quality and creativity, this place promises a unique experience with every visit. As a local, I adore the creative flavors on their menu and the laid-back yet engaging ambiance that makes you feel right at home.

Menu

5th and Jefferson Coffee House stands out with its culinary creativity, offering a menu that’s both comforting and adventurous. From their freshly baked scones and spicy chorizo bake to signature pulled pork burrito, every item is a testament to their commitment to good food with creative flavors. Their honey oat lavender latte and red velvet latte are must-tries for any coffee enthusiast.

Ambiance

Stepping into 5th and Jefferson is like entering a cozy and slightly Bohemian world. It’s a space where you can tuck away with a book in a quiet nook or mingle with friends on comfy couches. The atmosphere is effortlessly charming, inviting you to relax and savor the moment, whether you’re starting your day with a coffee or winding down with their delicious offerings.

Quick Facts

If you’re looking for a place where the coffee is just as impressive as the food, 5th and Jefferson Coffee House is the spot. With its welcoming vibe and an array of delicious choices, it’s no wonder this place is a hit among locals and visitors alike.

Old Mexico Cantina and Grill

A colorful Mexican food plate with tacos, bean and rice
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Nestled in the cozy corners of Sturgeon Bay, Old Mexico Cantina and Grill stands out as a gem, offering a taste of authentic Mexican cuisine. This charming spot at 901 Egg Harbor Rd wraps you in warmth and tantalizing aromas.

It’s where you can indulge in a long menu of Mexican and Tex-Mex delights that promise to satisfy every craving. Known for its cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, Old Mexico is a place where every meal feels like a celebration.

Menu

Dive into a world of rich flavors and vibrant dishes at Old Mexico. The menu is a delightful mix of traditional Mexican recipes and Tex-Mex favorites. Whether you’re craving the crunch of freshly made chips with guacamole or the comfort of a hearty burrito, the culinary offerings here are a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to authenticity and quality.

Ambiance

Old Mexico Cantina and Grill exudes a cozy, trendy vibe that makes every visit memorable. From the charming Mexican decor to the lively music, the atmosphere here is designed to transport you straight to the heart of Mexico. The restaurant’s thoughtful layout ensures that whether you’re dining solo, with a loved one, or in a group, you’re in for a comfortable and enjoyable experience.

Quick Facts

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Old Mexico Cantina and Grill is a must-visit spot for anyone looking to savor the true essence of Mexican cuisine in a friendly, welcoming setting.

Inn at Cedar Crossing

Elegant Dinner Setting Abstract Macro Background
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Inn at Cedar Crossing isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a landmark of Sturgeon Bay, standing proudly in the heart of downtown. It’s the perfect venue for a business lunch with its central location and a menu that serves up classic, wholesome dishes. The ambiance of the restaurant brings a cozy charm, making it a spot where time slows down, and you can enjoy good food and good company.

Menu

The menu at Inn at Cedar Crossing is a testament to the rich culinary heritage of Door County. It offers an array of options that cater to various palates, featuring American cuisine with a touch of elegance. The restaurant prides itself on its exceptional cuisine, which is as much a treat for the taste buds as it is a nod to the local bounty.

Ambiance

The historical significance of the building, dating back to 1884, adds a unique character to the inn, making it a blend of old-world charm and contemporary comfort. The plush setting of the dining area and the refined bar provide a warm, inviting atmosphere, perfect for those intimate conversations or relaxed evenings.

Quick Facts

Inn at Cedar Crossing offers a unique experience combining personalized hospitality, unique rooms, and delicious food and drink options, all within a historic and beautiful setting.

Samuelson’s Creek Pub and Grill

cheeseburger

Samuelson’s Creek Pub and Grill is a gem in Sturgeon Bay, a place where the local spirit is as rich as the flavors on your plate. Tucked away from the hustle, it’s where comfort meets style, and every meal feels like a celebration. Known for its cozy setting and mouth-watering dishes, this pub offers not just food, but an experience. It’s a spot where friends gather, laughter fills the air, and every bite tells a story of tradition and taste.

Menu

Delight in the diverse flavors at Samuelson’s Creek. Their menu is a treasure trove of choices, featuring everything from in-house smoked meats to a splendid array of burgers and barbecue. Don’t miss their Friday fish fry and Saturday steak night – each dish promising a burst of local flavor and heartwarming goodness.

Ambiance

At Samuelson’s Creek, expect a vibe that’s both welcoming and exclusive. It’s the kind of place where you can unwind after a long day, enjoy a casual meal under the sky on their lovely patio, or celebrate life’s little moments with a drink in hand. With its unique blend of casual elegance and heartwarming comfort, it’s more than just a dining spot; it’s where memories are made.

Quick Facts

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Samuelson’s Creek is a must-visit for anyone looking to savor the true essence of Sturgeon Bay’s culinary scene.

Drömhus

table setting at a restaurant in Door County
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Nestled in the heart of Sturgeon Bay, Drömhus, meaning “dream house” in Swedish, is a truly unique gem. This enchanting eatery, housed in a repurposed chapel, offers an experience that blends whimsy with a cozy charm.

As a Sturgeon Bay native, I’m always thrilled by the creativity and warmth Drömhus adds to our dining scene. The menu features a delightful array of small plates, perfectly paired with a carefully curated wine list and local beers. It’s not just about the food; it’s about the experience, where art and music create a lively spirit, making every visit memorable.

Menu

Drömhus takes your palate on a journey with its Scandinavian-inspired classics and modern favorites. From Swedish meatballs to lingonberry-Brie paninis and olive flights, the menu is an eclectic mix of flavors, all meant to be shared and savored. The venue is also known for hosting various events, adding a layer of community engagement and entertainment to your dining experience.

Ambiance

This venue, a former church, seamlessly blends historical charm with modern sensibility. The owner, Heather Weasler, has infused her vision into every corner, creating a space that’s both inviting and intriguing. The interior is a thoughtful mix of vintage and contemporary, with local art and whimsical elements that spark conversation and delight.

Quick Facts

In a town known for its vibrant dining scene, Drömhus stands out for its unique approach to combining food, art, and community. It’s a place that truly embodies the spirit of Sturgeon Bay, making it a must-visit destination for locals and visitors alike.

The Mill Supper Club

Golden delicious batter fried fish with french fries, tartar sauce, coleslaw, and ketchup.
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

A staple in the Sturgeon Bay dining scene, The Mill Supper Club merges traditional supper club charm with a German twist. As a local, I’ve always admired how The Mill maintains a balance between its historic roots and a contemporary dining experience.

The menu, rich with traditional and German fare, includes tender steaks, savory pasta, and unique sandwiches, not to mention the nightly specials and the famous family-style chicken. The Mill isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a slice of Door County’s history, inviting everyone to make memories over great food and service, just as they have since 1930.

Menu

Dive into the hearty world of The Mill’s menu, where each dish tells a story of tradition and taste. The German specialties like Schnitzel and Beef Rouladen are a nod to timeless flavors, while the American classics ensure there’s something for every palate. And for those special nights, the family-style chicken is a treat not to be missed.

Ambiance

The Mill Supper Club is where history meets modern comfort. The ambiance carries the legacy of a supper club that has stood the test of time since 1930. With a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to creating lasting memories for its guests, The Mill is more than just a meal; it’s an experience that brings people together.

Quick Facts

From its German cuisine with a modern twist to its deep-rooted history as a local gathering spot, The Mill Supper Club stands as a testament to the rich culinary tapestry of Sturgeon Bay.

Birmingham’s Bar and Cottages

3 hands holding cocktails in a bar
Via Unsplash. Used by permission.

Birmingham’s Bar and Cottages is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community cornerstone with a rich family history. This waterfront gem offers an array of homemade dishes that locals and visitors rave about.

Known for its hand-pattied burgers on white bread (yes, no buns!), Birmingham’s serves up grandma’s home cooking with favorites like pan-fried perch, chicken dinners, steaks, ribs, and seafood. It’s a third-generation family-owned spot where the friendly atmosphere and great cocktails make everyone feel right at home.

Menu

The menu at Birmingham’s Bar and Cottages is a testament to simple, delicious comfort food. Apart from the famous burgers on white bread, the menu features an assortment of sandwiches, pizzas, and a variety of side orders. With choices ranging from fresh-cut fries to beer-battered onion rings and cheese curds, there’s something to satisfy every craving. And for salad lovers, the menu offers a range of fresh and flavorful options.

Ambiance

Birmingham’s Bar and Cottages is your quintessential local haunt where the atmosphere is laid back, and the staff is known for their friendliness. It’s the kind of place where you can unwind, enjoy a hearty meal, and feel like part of the family. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Birmingham’s promises a warm welcome and an experience that embodies the spirit of Door County.

Quick Facts

With its delightful array of comfort foods, a cozy atmosphere, and a history of making guests feel right at home, Birmingham’s Bar and Cottages stands as a beloved institution in Sturgeon Bay.

The Hitching Post Bar & Grill

20230524-fish-fry

The Hitching Post Bar & Grill is more than just a dining spot; it’s a cozy retreat. This log cabin-style restaurant, with its hearty menu and inviting atmosphere, is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Known for its classic Friday Fish Fry and diverse menu that caters to all tastes, this place ensures you’re in for a good time and a great meal. And if you’re looking for a place to relax and unwind, The Hitching Post, with its welcoming ambiance and friendly service, has got you covered.

Menu

The Hitching Post prides itself on a menu that celebrates local flavors and classic comforts. With a spread that includes everything from mouthwatering starters to satisfying main courses, there’s something for everyone. And let’s not forget their famous Friday Fish Fry, a must-try tradition for any visitor!

Ambiance

Think of a warm, welcoming log cabin where every meal feels like a family gathering. That’s The Hitching Post for you. It’s the perfect spot to unwind after a long day or to gather with friends and family for a memorable meal. The rustic charm and cozy setting create an atmosphere that’s both relaxing and lively.

Quick Facts

Institute Saloon

cheeseburger
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

If walls could talk, the Institute Saloon would have tales for days. This Sturgeon Bay mainstay has been a local hub for over a century, and it’s not just the drinks that keep people coming. Stepping into the Institute Saloon is like stepping into history. It’s a place where the past isn’t just remembered; it’s felt.

Some say it’s even haunted, with stories of spirits lingering in its corners. But beyond the ghost tales, it’s the camaraderie and the sense of community that truly define this place. And let’s not forget the food and drinks, with a menu that keeps locals and visitors alike satisfied and coming back for more.

Menu

The Institute Saloon is known for its welcoming vibe and a menu that covers a range of hearty American classics. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick bite or a full meal, their offerings are sure to hit the spot, keeping both the stomach and the heart full.

Ambiance

The ambiance of the Institute Saloon is a blend of the traditional and the mystical. With a history dating back to 1895 and tales of the supernatural, this place offers an experience that’s both cozy and intriguing. It’s not just a place to dine; it’s a place to connect, share stories, and maybe even encounter the unexpected.

Quick Facts

The Gnoshery

coffee beans
Via Depositphotos. Used by permission.

Tucked away in Sturgeon Bay is a gem known as The Gnoshery, a cozy haven for board game enthusiasts and foodies alike. Established in 2021, this unique Board Game Cafe is not just a place to dine; it’s an experience.

It brings together the joy of tabletop gaming with delicious ‘gnoshables’ – snacks and treats from their kitchen. Imagine sipping a freshly brewed organic coffee while diving into a game of chess or laughing over Cards Against Humanity with friends.

Menu

The Gnoshery excels at offering a variety of organic fair-trade teas and coffees, curated worldwide and perfectly roasted. Smoothies and a wide assortment of tasty snacks ensure that you have all the fuel you need for an intense gaming session.

Ambiance

Step into The Gnoshery, and you enter a world of joy and camaraderie. The aroma of craft coffees and teas fills the air, while shelves stocked with every board game imaginable invite you to explore new worlds. It’s a place where the community gathers, friendships are forged, and every visit guarantees a new adventure on the tabletop.

Quick Facts

If you’re looking for a place that’s all about creating fun experiences and making memories, The Gnoshery is your go-to spot in Sturgeon Bay.

Sturgeon Bay Restaurants with Water Views

people dining at a waterfront restaurant in Door County, Wisconsin.

Sturgeon Bay offers a delightful dining experience with picturesque water views that add an extra layer of charm to your meal. Among the standout spots, Sonny’s Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria is a local favorite.

Not only does it serve gourmet Chicago Style Pizza and authentic Verace Pizza Napoletana, but it also offers an extensive menu including pastas, wings, salads, and desserts. The dining experience is elevated by the scenic views of the Michigan Street Steel Bridge, the marina, and the shipyard.

The sunsets overlooking the Bay from Sonny’s are particularly renowned, making it a must-visit spot for both locals and visitors seeking a memorable meal with a view.

In addition to Sonny’s, Stone Harbor is another gem in Sturgeon Bay, known for its waterfront dining where you can enjoy a meal while taking in the beautiful views of the bay. Both restaurants provide a unique atmosphere and a rich dining experience that’s enhanced by the serene backdrop of Sturgeon Bay’s waters.

Scene of people dining at a waterfront restaurant in Door County, Wisconsin.

Whether you’re in the mood for Italian cuisine at Sonny’s or the diverse offerings at Stone Harbor, these spots are sure to provide a dining experience that’s as pleasing to the palate as it is to the eye.

Perched along the serene shores of Lake Michigan, Donny’s Glidden Lodge Restaurant offers more than just a meal; it provides a picturesque dining experience. Renowned for its Certified Black Angus cuts and an array of fresh, quality ingredients, this culinary haven is a must-visit for anyone in Sturgeon Bay.

The restaurant’s inviting atmosphere, coupled with breathtaking views of the lake, sets the stage for an unforgettable dining affair. It’s a place where the food is as spectacular as the scenery, ensuring every visit is a feast for both the taste buds and the eyes​​.

Sturgeon Bay Restaurants with Outdoor Seating

Sturgeon Bay is not only known for its scenic beauty but also for its delightful dining spots with comfortable outdoor seating. These restaurants offer not just great food but also an inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy the fresh air and picturesque surroundings. Here are some notable spots:

  • Kitty O’Reilly’s Irish Pub: Known for its lively ambiance and a beer garden that’s perfect for outdoor dining.
  • Sonny’s Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria: Besides serving delicious Italian cuisine, Sonny’s offers an incredible view of the bay from their outdoor dining area​​.
  • Bluefront Cafe: A cozy spot with a bright and friendly atmosphere, known for its specialty sandwiches, signature salads, and homemade sweets. The cafe is a popular choice for a healthy and natural meal, served with a smile. Their outdoor seating is available in the summer, making it a perfect spot to enjoy their eclectic menu.

Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty Irish meal, an authentic Italian feast, or a healthy and natural dish, these Sturgeon Bay restaurants with outdoor seating offer a memorable dining experience.

Pet-Friendly Sturgeon Bay Restaurants

family dining with a dog in Door County

Sturgeon Bay is a haven for pet lovers, offering a variety of dining options where your furry friends are more than welcome. Enjoy your meal in the company of your beloved pet at these friendly locales. Here’s a list of pet-friendly eateries where both you and your four-legged companions can relax and savor the flavors of Sturgeon Bay:

  • Sonny’s Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria: A cozy spot where you can enjoy authentic Italian dishes with your pet by your side.
  • Stone Harbor Restaurant: Offers a fantastic waterfront dining experience where pets are welcome to join.
  • Kick Coffee: A great place to grab a cup of coffee with outdoor seating available for you and your pet.
  • Door County Coffee & Tea Co.: Known for its variety of caffeinated beverages and tasty eats, with pet-friendly outdoor seating.
  • Valmy Happy Hour: This neighborhood bar not only offers comfort food but also welcomes pets at their outdoor tables.
  • Bridge Up Brewing Company: Enjoy a variety of craft beer and specialized flavors, pet-friendly too.
  • Culver’s: Famous for its ButterBurgers and fresh frozen custard, and offers a few outdoor tables where pets are welcome​​.

Always call ahead to verify that the location is indeed pet-friendly and to ascertain any rules regarding pets.

Family-Friendly Sturgeon Bay Restaurants

family dining at a waterfront restaurant

Sturgeon Bay is a fantastic destination for families, offering a variety of restaurants that cater to all ages. These family-friendly eateries provide not just delicious meals but also a welcoming atmosphere that makes dining out with the whole family a pleasure. Here are some top choices:

  • Scaturo’s Baking Co. & Cafe: A cozy cafe with a charming ambiance, offering a range of baked goods and a delicious menu perfect for families​​.
  • Greystone Castle: A unique dining experience with a hunting-and-fishing theme, offering classic American fare in a friendly environment​.
  • Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub: Known for its relaxed atmosphere and live music, this Irish pub offers a pleasant space where families can enjoy good food and tunes​.
  • Betsy Ross Family Restaurant: A welcoming spot where breakfast is served all day, alongside a varied menu that includes everything from burgers to Italian dishes, perfect for any family meal​​.
  • Bluefront Café: Offers a fresh and eclectic lunch menu in a cozy and friendly cafe, with specialty sandwiches, signature salads, and homemade sweets, catering to various dietary preferences​​.

These restaurants are known for their delightful menus and warm, welcoming atmospheres, making them perfect for families looking to enjoy a meal together in Sturgeon Bay. Always call ahead to verify that the location is indeed family friendly.

Places to Eat in Sturgeon Bay

Table set with food. Superimposed text says: Best Restaurants Sturgeon Bay WI

Sturgeon Bay, the heart of Door County, offers a diverse array of dining experiences, making it a paradise for food lovers. Whether you’re craving the comfort of a homestyle diner, the elegance of a fine dining establishment, or the unique atmosphere of a thematic cafe, Sturgeon Bay has it all. Each eatery prides itself on providing not just meals, but memorable dining experiences. From waterfront views to cozy, tucked-away corners, these places to eat in Sturgeon Bay cater to every palate, ensuring that every meal is not just consumed but savored.

Dining in Sturgeon Bay

Table set with food overlooking a waterfront scene. Superimposed text says: "Sturgeon Bay Restaurant Bucket List."

Dining in Sturgeon Bay is a treat for the senses, offering a blend of culinary delights that cater to both the adventurous foodie and those seeking the comfort of classic dishes. Here, every restaurant tells a story, with menus rich in local produce and fresh, seasonal ingredients. The town’s vibrant dining scene boasts an eclectic mix of eateries, from quaint cafes and bustling bistros to elegant waterfront dining spots. Sturgeon Bay invites you to explore its culinary landscape, where each meal is a celebration of flavor and local charm.

Tips for Dining in Sturgeon Bay

  • Check Weather Before Dining Outdoors: The weather in Sturgeon Bay can cool down dramatically at night. If you’re planning to dine outdoors, it’s wise to bring a warm jacket or a blanket.
  • Verify Business Hours: Always call ahead or check online to confirm the operating hours of restaurants. In Door County, business hours can change frequently, and some establishments close seasonally.
  • Explore Local Seafood Options: Sturgeon Bay is known for its fresh seafood. Don’t miss the chance to try local specialties like whitefish or lake perch.
  • Consider Parking Options: Especially during peak seasons, parking can be challenging in popular areas. Check if the restaurant has its own parking lot or plan ahead for public parking spaces.
  • Be Prepared for Busy Times: Summer and fall can be particularly busy in Sturgeon Bay. It’s a good idea to make reservations well in advance, especially for popular restaurants.
  • Ask Locals for Recommendations: Don’t hesitate to ask local residents for their favorite dining spots. They often know the best places for unique dishes and the best views.
  • Explore the Wine Scene: Door County is home to several wineries. Consider trying local wines with your meal or visiting a nearby winery for a tasting experience.
  • Respect Local Etiquette: While Sturgeon Bay is a friendly place, it’s always good to be respectful of local customs and etiquette, especially in finer dining establishments.
  • Accommodate Special Dietary Needs in Advance: If you have special dietary needs or restrictions, check the menu online beforehand or call the restaurant to ensure they can accommodate your needs.
  • Savor the Sunset Views: If you’re dining near the water, time your dinner around sunset for a memorable view. Waterfront restaurants in Sturgeon Bay offer some stunning sunset vistas.

More Information about Sturgeon Bay

Sturgeon Bay is a great place to explore, and it is the “Door to Door County.” HelloDoorCounty.com is your best option to discover more about this great city right on the water.

Sturgeon Bay has lots of fun things to do to work off the calories from your dining excursion. Check out our article on Sturgeon Bay’s best attractions to find out more.

Perhaps you’re considering making Sturgeon Bay your homebase for a Door County vacation. If so, make sure to check out our article on Sturgeon Bay’s best hotels to find the perfect hotel for your party.

Find great deals on sturgeon bay hotels

Savoring Sturgeon Bay’s Dual Delights

Sturgeon Bay, where industry and tourism harmoniously coexist, offers a culinary journey like no other. The restaurants of Sturgeon Bay cater to shipyard workers and Big City elite alike. As you savor the flavors of Sturgeon Bay, you’ll discover that this unique city has something special for every palate.

About the author
Mark Stoneman
Hi! My name is Mark! I have been a resident of Door County for almost ten years now, and I'm glad to help you say "Hello" to Door County. I believe that travel helps to change lives, and because of that, I want to help you improve your life through travel.

Leave a Comment